A Critical Perspective on ECtHR Jurisprudence on Racial Profiling in Policing: Three Proposals to Ameliorate Victims’ Access to Justice
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v27.10226Keywords:
racial profiling in policing , anti-discrimination law , European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR), Article 14 European Convention on Human Rights, Seydi and others v. France.Abstract
In this article we undertake a critical analysis of the ECtHR jurisprudence regarding racial profiling in policing. The goal of the paper is to contribute to the discussion on ways to increase opportunities for access to justice for victims of racial profiling. Our proposals focus mainly on the following hypotheses: i) antidiscrimination law must clearly identify the social group that it aims to protect; ii) a “colour-blind” perspective of racial equality must be avoided to better define these cases; iii) courts must analyse, to determine whether racial profiling exists, police officers’ justification for the identity check process (not the existence of a racist attitude or motivation).
Downloads
References
ÁLVAREZ DEL CUVILLO, A. (2022). “El problema de la discriminación inversa: ¿Es posible discriminar a quienes pertencen a los grupos sociales dominantes?”. Trabajo, Persona, Derecho, Mercado, 5, pp. 187–209.
ARAÚJO, M. AND MAESO, S. R. (2021). “The Power of Racism in Academia. Knowledge Production and Political Disputes”. In: Santos B. S. and Martins B. (Eds.), The Pluriverse of Human Rights. The Diversity of Struggles for Dignity, pp. 186–204. New York: Routledge.
BARRÈRE UNZUETA, M. A. (2018). “Filosofías del Derecho Positivo ¿Qué Derecho y qué discriminación? Una visión contrahegemónica del Derecho Antidiscriminatorio”. Anuario de Filosofía del Derecho, XXXIV, pp. 11–42.
BONILLA-SILVA, E. (2003). “New Racism”, Color-Blind Racism, and the Future of Whiteness in America. In: Doane, A. W. and Bonilla-Silva, E. (Eds.), White Out: The Continuing Significance of Racism, pp. 319–335. New York and London: Routledge.
CARMICHAEL, S. AND HAMILTON, C. V. (1967). Poder negro. México: Siglo XXI.
DEUTSCH, M. (2006). “A framework for thinking about oppression and its change”. Social Justice Research, 19, pp. 7–41.
ECRI General Policy Recommendation n° 11 on combating racism and racial discrimination in policing adopted on 29 June 2007.
ELLWOOD, C. A. (1912). Sociology in its psychological aspects. New York and London: D. Appleton and Company.
EUROPEAN UNION AGENCY FOR FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS. (2010). Towards More Effective Policing Understanding and Preventing Discriminatory Ethnic Profiling: A Guide [Online]. Available at: https://fra.europa.eu/sites/default/files/fra_uploads/1133-Guide-ethnic-profiling_EN.pdf (Accessed: 15 April 2026).
FITZPATRICK, P. (1987). “Racism and the Innocence of Law”. Journal of Law and Society, 14, pp. 119–132.
FOUCAULT, M. (1992). Microfísica del Poder. Madrid: La Piqueta.
FREEMAN, A. D. (1978). “Legitimizing Racial Discrimination through Antidiscrimination law: A Critical Review of Supreme Court Doctrine”. Minnesota Law Review, 62(6), pp. 1049–1119.
GARCÍA AÑON, J. (2024). “Discriminación y experiencias en la identificación policial por perfil étnico: la evolución en España diez años después”. Cuadernos Electrónicos de Filosofía del Derecho, 52, pp. 55–83.
GASCÓN CUENCA, A. (2025). “La utilización de perfiles étnicos como una práctica de discriminación sistémica de carácter institucional: análisis de la sentencia del Tribunal Europeo de Derechos Humanos Wa Baile contra Suiza”. Derechos y Libertades, 53, pp. 211–237.
GESSER, M. ET AL. (2022). “Estudios Sobre Discapacidad: interseccionalidad, anticapacitismo y emancipación social”. Andamios, 19(49), pp. 217–240.
GIL, D. G. (1998). Confronting Social Injustice and Oppression: Concepts and Strategies for Social Workers. New York: Columbia University Press.
HART ELY, J. (1998). “The Supreme Court, 1977 Term: Foreword: On Discovering Fundamental Values”. Harvard Law Review, 92, pp. 5–55.
HENRARD, K. (2023). “The European Court of Human Rights and the Distribution of the Burden of Proof in Racial Discrimination Cases: The Search for Fairness Continues”. European Convention on Human Rights Law Review, 4(4), pp. 426–446.
HOPKINS, T. AND POPOVIC, G. (2025). “Do Australian police engage in racial profiling? A method for identifying racial profiling in the absence of police data”. Current Issues in Criminal Justice, 37(1), pp. 19–40.
JACKSON ET AL. (2023). “Centering race in procedural justice theory: Structural racism and the under- and overpolicing of Black communities”. Law and Human Behavior, 47(1), pp. 68–82.
JOHNSON, A. G. (2000). The Blackwell dictionary of sociology: A user's guide to sociological Language. Cambridge and Oxford: Blackwell Publishers.
KHANNA, V. (2025). Seydi and Others v. France: Proving Racial Profiling in Discrimination Law. Strasbourg Observers, 4 December. Available at: https://strasbourgobservers.com/2025/12/04/seydi-and-others-v-france-proving-racial-profiling-in-discrimination-law/ (Accessed: 15 April 2026).
LEVY, N. (2017). Am I a racist? Implicit bias and the ascription of racism. The Philosophical Quarterly, 67(268), pp. 534–551.
LIGHTEN, J. -J. (2025). “Identity Checks in France in Violation of Article 14 Post-Wa Baile v. Switzerland”. Chicago Journal of International Law, 5(1), pp. 407–427.
LÓPEZ-RIBA, J. M. (2021). “El análisis cuantitativo de las identificaciones y las detenciones policiales en España: Datos disponibles, limitaciones e implicaciones”. Revista Española de Investigación Criminológica, 19(2), pp. 1–30.
MACNICOL, J. (2015). Neoliberalising Old Age. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
MOGENSEN, A. (2019). Racial Profiling and Cumulative Injustice. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 98(2), pp. 259–522.
OCHOA RUIZ, N. M. (2023). “Los controles policiales de identidad por motivos discriminatorios en la jurisprudencia del Tribunal Europeo de Derechos Humanos: un comentario a la sentencia Muhammad c. España”. Crónica de Derecho Internacional Público, Revista Electrónica de Estudios Internacionales, 45, pp. 24–30.
OPPENHEIMER, D. B. (2008). “Why France Needs to Collect Data on Racial Identity… In a French Way”. Hastings International Comparative Law Review, 31(2), pp. 735–752.
OULED, Y. M. AND KORRICHE, S. J. (2024). Racismo policial en el Estado español. Un análisis cualitativo del sesgo racial en la práctica de parada, identificación y registro policial [Online]. Íridia. Available at: https://rightsinternationalspain.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/Informe_racismo_policial-RIS-IRIDIA.pdf (Accessed: 15 April 2026).
PAYNE, K. and HANNAY, J. W. (2021). “Implicit bias reflects systemic racism”. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 25(11), pp. 927–936.
POLO NAVARRO, P. (2020). Propostes per unes identificacions policials no discriminatòries. Mesures efectives de prevenció, control i erradicació de les actuacions policials de caràcter racista [Online]. Generalitat de Catalunya. Available at https://igualtat.gencat.cat/web/.content/Ambits/drets-igualtats/informes-DDHH/identificacions-policials.pdf (Accessed: 2 February 2026).
REIBETANZ MOREAU, S. (2006). “Equality Rights and the Relevance of Comparator Groups”. Journal of Law and Equality, 5(1), pp. 81–95.
REY MARTÍNEZ, F. (2021). “El organismo español para la igualdad: claves para su convergencia con el modelo europeo”. Revista Galega de Administración Pública, EGAP, 61, pp. 311–342.
REY MARTÍNEZ, F. (2023). Manual de instrucciones para utilizar el concepto de igualdad a fin de que las minorías étnicas no la alcancen. (Sentencia del Tribunal Supremo Federal norteamericano SFA, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College y University of North Carolina, de 29 de junio de 2023). Revista Española de Derecho Constitucional, 129, pp. 267–303.
SÁNCHEZ TOMÁS, J. M. (2024). “Los controles policiales de identidad por perfil racial en España y el TEDH (STEDH 18-10-2022, caso Muhammad c. España)”. Revista Crítica Penal y Poder (Nueva Época), 26, pp. 1–15.
SANTOS, B. S. (2002). “Para uma sociologia das ausências e uma sociologia das emergências”. Revista Crítica de Ciências Sociais, 63, pp. 237–280.
SCHCLAREK MULINARI, L. (2025). “Criminalizing Style: Aesthetic Injustice and Racial Profiling in Sweden”. The British Journal of Criminology, XX, pp. 1–16.
STREICHER, B. (2022). Tackling racial profiling: reflections on recent case law of the European Court of Human Rights. Strasbourg Observers. Available at: https://strasbourgobservers.com/2022/12/16/tackling-racial-profiling-reflections-on-recent-case-law-of-the-european-court-of-human-rights/ (Accessed: 15 April 2026).
TIMMER, A. S. H. (2015). “Judging Stereotypes: What the European Court of Human Rights Can Borrow from American and Canadian Equal Protection Law”. American Journal of Comparative Law, 63(1), pp. 239–284.
VAN HAITSMA, M. (1989). A Contextual Definition of the Underclass”. Focus (Institute for Research on Poverty, University of Wisconsin, Madison), 12(1), pp. 27–31.
VÁRNAGY, E. AND NÍ CHINNÉide, H. (2024). “Divorcing the Substantive from the Procedural in Racist Police Violence Cases at the ECtHR: A Just Institutional Approach?”. Utrecht Law Review, 20(4), pp. 65–82.
YOUNG, I. M. (1990). Justice and the Politics of Difference. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
CASE LAW
ECtHR, Basu v. Germany, Application No. 215/19, 18 October 2022.
ECtHR, D. H. and Others v. the Czech Republic, Application No. 57325/00, 13 November 2007.
ECtHR, Muhammad v. Spain, Application No. 34085/17, 18 October 2022.
ECtHR, Timishev v. Russia, Application Nos. 55762/00 and 55974/0013, 13 December 2005.
ECtHR, Seydi and others v. France, Application No. 35844/17, 26 June 2025.
ECtHR, Wa Baile v. Switzerland, Application Nos. 43868/18 and 25883/21, 20 February 2024.
Spanish Constitutional Court (Second Chamber), 13/2001, of 29 January 2001 (BOE 52, 1st March 2001).
Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College, 600 U. S. (2023).
United States v. Carolene Products Co. 304 U. S. 144 (1938).
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Anna
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
