The Flotilla Incident from the Perspective of International Law and the Judicial Rights of the Victims
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v15.5817Keywords:
Compensation Agreement, International Criminal Court, International Law, Mavi Marmara flotilla, San RemoAbstract
The Mavi Marmara flotilla, which sailed for a humanitarian mission and aimed to break the Israeli blockade to Gaza, was intercepted by the Israeli soldiers on high sea on 31st May 2010. In this raid, nine civilians have lost their lives on the spot and 55 others were wounded. States and their agents can be held accountable if they commit crimes. Therefore, the Mavi Marmara victims have the right to sue at national and international level the Israeli officers who took part in the operation. Some victims have filed criminal and civil cases before the Turkish courts against Israel and its officers. Besides these judicial cases brought before the national courts, a referral was also made by the Union of the Comoros, flag country of the Mavi Marmara vessel, to the International Criminal Court. Meanwhile, Turkey and Israel have signed a bilateral agreement for the compensation of the bereaved families. This compensation agreement clears Israel and its officers off all legal responsibilities arising from the flotilla incident before the Turkish courts. This bilateral agreement is a legal obstruction imposed to the victims in their quest of justice. The Turkish Court of Cassation, in its recent decisions, has requested the courts of first instance to take into consideration the provisions of the said agreement. Despite the above mentioned agreement, the victims shall have still the right to sue the Israeli officials responsible for the flotilla incident before national, foreign and international courts, on the grounds of crime against humanity, provided that the necessary requirements are fulfilled.
References
AKSAR, Y. (Spring 2012) 'Birleşmiş Milletler Palmer (Mavi Marmara) Raporu ve Uluslararası Hukuk' (United Nations Palmer (Mavi Marmara) Report and International Law), Uluslararası İlişkiler (Journal of International Relations), Vol: 9, Issue: 33, pp. 26-30.
Amnesty International. (14 June 2017) Gaza: Looming Humanitarian Catastrophe Highlights Need To Lift Israel's 10 Year Illegal Blockade. Available at www.amnesty.org/en/latest/ews/2017/06/gaza-looming-humanitarian-catastrophe-highlights-need-to-lift-israels-10-year-illegal-blockade/ (Accessed: 8 October 2019).
CANÇADO TRINDADE, A.A. (2008) Evolution du Droit international au droit des gens - L'accès des particuliers à la justice internationale: le regard d'un juge. Paris: Pédone.
COHEN, A., and TAL, M. (4 July 2016) 'Israel's agreement with Turkey: Does it protect IDF soldiers from prosecution?'. Available at https://www.jpost.com/Opinion/Israels-agreement-with-Turkey-Does-it-protect-IDF-soldiers-from-prosecution-459487 (Accessed: 4 December 2019).
Convention for the Suppression of Unlawful Acts Against the Safety of Maritime Navigation. Available at www.imo.org./en/About/Conventions/ListofConventions/Pages/SUA-Treaties.aspx (Accessed: 19 September 2019).
FINKELSTEIN, N. (2014) 'What Happened on the Mavi Marmara? An Analysis of the Turkel Commission Report', Türkiye Ortadoğu Çalışmaları Dergisi (Turkish Journal of Middle Eastern Studies), Vol: 1, Issue: 2, pp. 31-53.
Geneva Convention Relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War. 12 August 1949.
Haaretz. (26 May 2014) Turkey court issues arrest warrants over flotilla raid. Available at www.haaretz.com/amp/turkey-court-issues-arrest-warrants-over-flotilla-raid-1.5249667(Accessed: 29 February 2020).
International Criminal Court. (2002) Rules of Procedure and Evidence.
International Criminal Court. (23 April 2009) Regulations of the Office of the Prosecutor, ICC-BD/05-01-09.
International Criminal Court, Office of the Prosecutor. (6 November 2014) Situation on Registered Vessels of Comoros, Greece and Cambodia-Article 53(1) Report. Available at http://www.icc-cpi.int/iccdocs/otp/OTP-COM-Article_53(1)-Report-06Nov2014Eng.pdf (Accessed: 3 November 2019).
International Criminal Court, Pre-Trial Chamber I. (16 July 2015) Decision on the request of the Union of the Comoros to review the Prosecutor's decision not to initiate an investigation, ICC-01/13-34.
International Criminal Court, Office of the Prosecutor. (27 July 2015) Notice of Appeal against the Decision on the request of the Union of the Comoros to review the Prosecutor's decision not to initiate an investigation, ICC-01/13-35.
International Criminal Court, Appeals Chamber. (6 November 2015) Decision on the admissibility of the Prosecutor's appeal against the Decision on the request of the Union of the Comoros to review the Prosecutor's decision not to initiate an investigation, ICC-01/13-51.
International Criminal Court, Office of the Prosecutor. (29 November 2017) Notice of Prosecutor's Final Decision under Rule 108(3) with Public Annexes 1, A-C, and E-G, and Confidential Annex D, ICC-01/13-57.
International Criminal Court, Pre-Trial Chamber I. (15 November 2018) Decision on the Application for Judicial Review by the Government of the Union of the Comoros, ICC- 01/13-68.
International Criminal Court, Office of the Prosecutor. (21 November 2018) Request for Leave to Appeal the Decision on the Application for Judicial Review by the Government of the Union of the Comoros, ICC-01/13-69.
International Criminal Court, Appeals Chamber. (2 September 2019) Judgment on the appeal of the Prosecutor against Pre-Trial Chamber I's Decision on the Application for Judicial Review by the Government of the Union of the Comoros, ICC-01/13-98.
International Criminal Court, Office of the Prosecutor. (2 December 2019) Notice of Prosecutor's Final Decision under rule 108(3), as revised and re-filed in accordance with the Pre-Trial Chamber's request of 15 November 2018 and the Appeals Chamber's judgment of 2 September 2019, and Annex 1, ICC-01/13-99.
International Criminal Court. (2 September 2019) Press Release. Available at https://www.icc-cpi.int//Pages/item.aspx?name=pr1477 (Accessed: 3 November 2019).
International Justice Resource Center. Available at https://ijrcenter.org/cases-before-national-courts/domestic-exercise-of-universal-jurisdiction/ (Accessed: 24 February 2020).
Israeli National Report-1 on the Flotilla Incident. (January 2011) The Public Commission to Examine the Maritime Incident of 31 May 2010, The Turkel Commission. Report Part One. Available at www.gov.il/Blobfolder/generalpage/downloads_eng1/ENG_turkel_eng_a.pdf (Accessed: 28 February 2020).
Israeli National Report-2 on the Flotilla Incident. (February 2013) The Public Commission to Examine the Maritime Incident of 31 May 2010, The Turkel Commission, Second Report, Israel's Mechanisms for Examining and Investigating Complaints and Claims of Violations of the Laws of Armed Conflict According to International Law. Available at www.gov.il/Blobfolder/generalpage/downloads_eng1/ENG_turkel_eng_b1-474.pdf (Accessed: 28 February 2020).
Karar (Turkish newspaper). (23 May 2018) Mavi Marmara anlaşması neden iptal edilmiyor? Available at www.karar.com/yazarlar/elif-cakir/mavi-marmara-anlasmasi-neden-iptal-edilmiyor-7045 (Accessed: 24 February 2020).
LONGOBARDO, M. (September 2016) 'Everything Is Relative, Even Gravity: Remarks on the Assessment of Gravity in ICC Preliminary Examinations, and the Mavi Marmara Affair', Journal of International Criminal Justice, Volume: 14, No: 4, pp. 1011-1030. https://doi.org/10.1093/jicj/mqw027
LONGOBARDO, M. (November 2016) 'Factors Relevant for the Assessment of Sufficient Gravity in the ICC. Proceedings and the Elements of International Crimes', Questions of International Law (QIL), Zoom-in 33 (2016), pp. 21-41. Available at http://www.qil-qdi.org/factors-relevant-assessment-sufficient-gravity-icc-proceedings-elements-international-crimes/ (Accessed: 30 August 2020).
Meclis Haber (Turkish Parliament's News Website). (17 August 2016) Press Release of the Turkish Parliament-Foreign Affairs Commission. Available at https://meclishaber.tbmm.gov.tr/develop/owa/haber_portal.aciklama?p1=137895 (Accessed: 29 August 2020).
MELONI, C. (2016) 'The ICC Preliminary Examination Of The Flotilla Situation: An Opportunity To Contextualise Gravity', Questions of International Law (QIL), Zoom- in 33 (2016), pp. 3-20. Available at http://www.qil-qdi.org/icc-preliminary-examination-flotilla-situation-opportunity-contextualise-gravity/ (Accessed: 29 August 2020).
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Israel. (2010) Available at https://mfa.gov.il/mfa/foreignpolicy/issues/pages/seizure_gaza_flotilla_31-may-2010.aspx (Accessed: 20 October 2019).
'Procedural Agreement on Compensation Between the Republic of Turkey and the State of Israel', Ankara and Jerusalem, 28 June 2016. in the Official Journal of the Republic of Turkey, Issue: 29826, 9 September 2016.
REUTERS. (5 June 2010) 'Gaza blockade illegal, must be lifted-UN's Pillay'. Available at https://www.reuters.com/article/israel-flotilla-un/gaza-blockade-illegal-must-be-lifted-uns-pillay-idUSLDE65404020100605 (Accessed: 14 October 2019).
San Remo Manual on International Law Applicable to Armed Conflicts at Sea. Available at http://www.icrc.org/Eng/Resources/Documents/Misc/57jmsu.Htm (Accessed: 06 November 2019).
Statute of the International Court of Justice. 26 June 1945.
T24 (Turkish online newspaper). (30 August 2016) Milli Gazete: Mavi Marmara mutabakatı anayasaya aykırı. Available at www.t24.com.tr/haber/milli-gazete-mavi-marmara-mutabakati-anayasaya-aykiri,357522 (Accessed: 26 February 2020).
T24 (Turkish online newspaper). (29 September 2019) Yargıtay, Mavi Marmara'da yaralananlar için tazminat yolunu açtı. Available at https://t24.com.tr/haber/yargitay-mavi-marmara-da-yaralananlar-icin-tazminat-yolunu-acti,841478 (Accessed: 29 December 2019).
The Guardian. (2010) UN condemns Israel's assault on Gaza flotilla. Available at www.theguardian.com/world/2010/jun/01/un-condemns-israel-assault-gaza-flotilla (Accessed: 18 October 2019).
The Independent. (5 August 2014) Israel-Gaza conflict: Right-wing Israeli politician calls for Gazans to be concentrated in camps. Available at www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/israel-gaza-conflict-right-wing-israeli-politician-calls-for-gazans-to-be-concentrated-in-camps-and-9649103.html (Accessed: 10 November 2019).
Turkish Constitution. English text available at www.tbmm.gov.tr/docs/constitution (Accessed: 24 February 2020).
Turkish Court of Cassation, Fourth Civil Chamber. File no: 2018/3128, Decision no and date: 2018/6193, (15.10.2018).
Turkish Court of Cassation, Fourth Civil Chamber. File no: 2017/5003, Decision no and date: 2019/3543, (25.06.2019).
Turkish Court of Cassation, Fourth Civil Chamber. File no: 2018/5365, Decision no and date: 2019/3544, (25.06.2019).
Turkish Court of Cassation, Fourth Civil Chamber. File no: 2019/105, Decision no and date: 2019/3545, (25.06.2019).
Turkish Court of Cassation, Fourth Civil Chamber. File no: 2018/3474, Decision no and date: 2019/3560, (25.06.2019).
Turkish Court of Cassation, Fourth Civil Chamber. File no: 2019/2989, Decision no and date: 2019/6283, (26.12.2019).
Turkish Court of Cassation, Fourth Civil Chamber. File no: 2019/2153, Decision no and date: 2019/6284, (26.12.2019).
Turkish Court of Cassation, Fourth Civil Chamber. File no: 2019/2899, Decision no and date: 2019/6285, (26.12.2019).
Turkish Court of Cassation, Fourth Civil Chamber. File no: 2019/2815, Decision no and date: 2019/6286, (26.12.2019).
Turkish National Report on the Flotilla Incident. (February 2011) Turkish National Commission of Inquiry, Report on the Israeli Attack on the Humanitarian Aid Convoy to Gaza on 31 May 2010, Ankara,. Available at http://www.mfa.gov.tr/data/Turkish%20Report%20Final%20-%20UN%20Copy.pdf (Accessed: 14 September 2019).
Türkiye Büyük Millet Meclisi Dışişleri Komisyonu (Turkish Grand National Assembly-Foreign Affairs Commission), 26'ncı Yasama Dönemi Birinci Yasama Yılı 32'nci toplantısı (32nd meeting of the 26th Legislative Term), Tutanak Dergisi (Minutes Journal), 17 August 2016, Wednesday, p. 16.
Uluslararası Hak İhlalleri İzleme Merkezi (International Center for Watching Violations of Rights). (23 June 2010) Mavi Marmara katliamının hukuki boyutu. Available at https://www.uhim.org/mavi-marmara-katliaminin-hukuki-boyutu.html (Accessed: 20 October 2019).
Union of the Comoros. (14 May 2013) Letter of Referral under Articles 14 and 12(2)(a) of the Rome Statute Arising from the 31 May 2010, Gaza Freedom Flotilla Situation. Available at http://www.icc-cpi.int/iccdocs/otp/Referral-from-Comoros.pdf (Accessed: 3 November 2019).
Union of the Comoros. (29 January 2015) 'Situation on Registered Vessels of the Union of the Comoros, The Hellenic Republic of Greece and the Kingdom of Cambodia, Application for Review pursuant to Article 53(3)
(a) of the Prosecutor's Decision of 6 November 2014 not to initiate an investigation into the Situation', ICC-01/13-3-Red.
Union of the Comoros. (23 February 2018) 'Situation on Registered Vessels of the Union of the Comoros, The Hellenic Republic of Greece and the Kingdom of Cambodia, Application for Judicial Review by the Government of the Union of the Comoros', ICC-01/13-58-Red.
Union of the Comoros. (2 March 2020) 'Situation on Registered Vessels of the Union of the Comoros, The Hellenic Republic of Greece and the Kingdom of Cambodia, Application for Judicial Review by the Government of the Comoros', ICC-01/13-100.
United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea. 1982.
UN Human Rights Council. (2009) Human Rights in Palestine and Other Occupied Arab Territories: Report of the United Nations Fact-Finding Mission on the Gaza Conflict. A/HRC/12/48, Twelfth Session, 25 September 2009. Available at www2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/hrcouncil/docs/UNFFMGC_Report.pdf (Accessed: 27 February 2020).
UN Human Rights Council. (2010) Report of the International Fact-Finding Mission to Investigate Violations of International Law, Including International Humanitarian and Human Rights Law, Resulting from the Israeli Attacks on the Flotilla of Ships Carrying Humanitarian Assistance. A/HRC/15/21, Fifteenth Session, 27 September 2010. Available at www2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/hrcouncil/docs/15Session/A.HRC.15.21_en.pdf (Accessed: 27 February 2020).
UN Human Rights Council. (2010) Resolution adopted by the Human Rights Council no: 14/, dated 2 June 2010. Available at httsp://unispal.un.org/DPA/DPR/unispal.nsf/ (Accessed: 23 October 2019).
UN News. (2010) Available at https://news.un.org/en/story/2010/05/340222-secretary-general-shocked-deadly-raid-gaza-aid-flotilla (Accessed: 18 October 2019).
UN Radio. (25 January 2010) 'UNRWA says Israeli blockade continues to cause suffering to the Palestinians- UN Radio feed'. Available at www.un.org/unispal/document/auto-insert-203110/ (Accessed: 14 October 2019).
UNSG Panel of Inquiry Report. (July 2011) Report of the Secretary-General's Panel of Inquiry on the 31 May 2010 Flotilla Incident. Available at https://unispal.un.org/UNISPAL.NSF/0/1922B40C9F4575598525790300457132 (Accessed: 28 February 2020).
