Foreign Terrorist Fighters and the UN Investigative Team to Support Domestic Efforts to Hold ISIS Accountable for War Crimes, Crimes Against Humanity and Genocide Committed in Iraq: Building a Bridge that Should Be Used

Montserrat Abad Castelos

doi:10.17561/tahrj.v16.6302

Authors

Montserrat Abad Castelos

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v16.6302

Keywords:

ISIS, foreign terrorist fighters, UNITAD, atrocity crimes, Iraq, jurisdiction

Abstract

After examining the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) resolutions referred to the foreign fighters who joined the ranks of ISIS in Iraq and Syria andthe UN Investigative Team to support domestic efforts to hold ISIS accountable for war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide committed in Iraq (UNITAD or the Investigative Team) this article brings both contents together in order to ascertain whether there may be gaps or problems which should be addressed, since both developments were prompted by the UNSC. It is explored whether there may be certain inconsistencies, such as the one relating to the emphasis placed on different crimes, depending on the resolutions in question. Thus, those related to FTFs focus on terrorism crimes, while those related to UNITAD refer to atrocity crimes. Hereinafter the action and evolution of UNITAD is examined, in order to determine whether it might be helpful to overcome some existing barriers and avoid impunity for atrocity crimes. It will be concluded that UNITAD may provide substantial support, not only in relation to trials in Iraq, but also in third States, by providing useful tools or evidence to prosecute FTFs. Seizing this opportunity will require further action, which will be crucial to promote accountability and justice.

References

ABAD CASTELOS, M. (2019), ¿Es posible combatir el terrorismo yihadista a través de la justicia? El retorno de los combatientes del Estado islámico tras sus crímenes, Barcelona: J.M. Bosch. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctvq2w4jh

AMBOS, K. (2014), "'Our Terrorists, Your Terrorists? The UNSC Urges States to Combat 'Foreign Terrorist Fighters'", but Does not Define 'Terrorism', EJIL: Talk!, 2 October 2014. Available at https://www.ejiltalk.org/our-terrorists-your-terrorists- the-united-nations-security-council-urges-states-to-combat-foreign-terrorist- fighters-but-does-not-define-terrorism/

BILKOVÁ, V. (2018), "Foreign Terrorist Fighters and International Law", Groningen Journal of International Law, Vol. 6, Number 1, pp. 1-23. https://doi.org/10.21827/5b51d51a22ac3

CLOONEY, A. (2017), 'Finally, We Have a Coordinated Effort to Bring ISIS to Justice', The Huffpost, September 22, 2017. Available at https://www.huffingtonpost.com/ entry/amal-clooney-isis_us_59c569bae4b01cc57ff22947?guccounter=1).

DE KERCHOVE, G. (2016), 'Foreword', in Foreign Fighters under International Law and Beyond, A. De Guttry, A. Capone, F. and C. Paulussen (eds.), Springer / Asser Press: The Hague.

FREEMAN, L. (2020), 'Prosecuting Atrocity Crimes with Open Source Evidence: Lessons from the International Criminal Court', in Digital Witness. Using Open Source Information for Human Rights Investigation, Documentation and Accountability, Oxford University Press, pp. 48-67.

FUKUYAMA, F. (2018), Identity: The Demand for Dignity and the Politics of Resentment, London: Profile Books.

GILMORE, S.A. (2018), 'Introductory Note to United Nations Security Council Resolution 2379', The American Society of International Law. https://doi.org/10.1017/ilm.2018.41

HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH:

- (2017), Flawed Justice. Accountability for ISIS Crimes in Iraq, December 5, 2017. Available at https://www.hrw.org/report/2017/12/05/flawed-justice/ accountability-isis-crimes-iraq#

- (2020), How to Answer Iraq's Dangerous Failure to Put a Stop to Torture (written by B. WILLE), Available at https://www.hrw.org/news/2020/09/16/ how-answer-iraqs-dangerous-failure-put-stop-torture

ICC (2015), Statement of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, Fatou Bensouda, on the Alleged Crimes Committed by ISIS (8 April 2015). Available at https://www.icc-cpi.int/Pages/item.aspx?name=otp-stat-08-04-2015-1.

ICRC (2015), 32nd International Conference of the Red Cross and Red Crescent, Doc. EN32ic/15/11 (December 2015).

KLAUSEN, J. (2019), 'Jihadists Head Home Thousands of Westerns Joined ISIS. Should They Be Allowed to Return', Foreign Affairs, June 6, 2019. Available at https:// www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/europe/2019-06-06/jihadists-head-home

MALET, D. (2018), 'The European Experience with Foreign Fighters and Returnees', in Returnees: Who Are They, Why Are they (not) Coming Back and How Should We Deal with Them? Assessing Policies on Returning Foreign Terrorist Fighters in Belgium, Germany and the Netherlands, T. Renard and R. Coolsaet (eds.), Egmont Paper 101 (February 2018).

MARRERO ROCHA, I. (2019), 'The European Union's Foreign 'Terrorist' Fighters', in Jihadism, Foreign Fighters and Radicalization in the EU. Legal, Functional and Psychosocial Responses, I. Marrero Rocha and H. M. Trujillo Mendoza (eds.), London and New York: Routledge, pp. 44-63. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429468506-4

MARTÍN RODRÍGUEZ, P. (2019), 'The Rule of Law and the Fight against Terrorism and Radicalization in the European Union', in Jihadism, Foreign Fighters and Radicalization in the EU. Legal, Functional and Psychosocial Responses, I. Marrero Rocha and H. M. Trujillo Mendoza (eds.), London and New York: Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429468506-8

MATAR, J. (2019), The War Report. Iraq: Any Hope for Change?, The Geneva Academy (November 2019), at 2. Available at https://www.geneva-academy.ch/joomlatools- files/docman-files/Iraq%20Any%20Hope%20for%20Change.pdf

MEHRA, T., and PAULUSSEN, C. (2019), 'The Repatriation of Foreign Fighters and Their Families: Options, Obligations, Morality and Long-Term Thinking', International Centre for Counter-Terrorism, The Hague, March 6, 2019. Available at https:// icct.nl/publication/the-repatriation-of-foreign-fighters-and-their-families-options- obligations-morality-and-long-term-thinking/

NI AOLÁIN, F. (2017), Letter of the UN Special Rapporteur on the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights while Countering Terrorism, September 22, 2017.

NI AOLÁIN, F. (2018), 'The UN Security Council, Global Watch Lists, Biometrics, and the Threat to the Rule of Law', 17 Just Security, January. Available at https:// www.justsecurity.org/51075/security-council-global-watch-lists-biometrics/

OCHAB, E.U. (2018), 'Known Genocidaires and Daesh Foreign Fighters Avoid Prosecutions in the UK', Forbes, April 27, 2018. Available at https://www.forbes. com/sites/ewelinaochab/2018/04/27/known-genocidaires-and-daesh-foreign- fighters-avoid-prosecutions-in-the-uk/#1e5e16ca76cf

OCHAB, E.U. (2019), 'Attempts to Address the Issue of Foreign Terrorist Fighters Continue', Forbes, February 22, 2019. Available at https://www.forbes.com/ sites/ewelinaochab/2019/02/22/attempts-to-address-the-issue-of-foreign-fighters- continue/#4727f7641cd2.

OLÁSOLO, H., and GALAIN PALERMO, P. (2018), Los desafíos del Derecho internacional penal, Tirant: Valencia.

OSCE and UNOCT (2020), "OSCE and UNOCT discuss ways to responsibly use passenger data to prevent return of foreign terrorist fighters", Press release, October 30, 2020. Available at https://www.un.org/counterterrorism/sites/www.un.org. counterterrorism/files/20202030_press_release_comprehensive_input_comms. pdf

PAULUSSEN, C., CUYCKENS, H., and FORTIN, K. (2019), 'The Prosecution of Foreign Fighters under International Humanitarian Law: Misconceptions and Opportu- nities', International Centre for Counter-Terrorism, The Hague, December 13, 2019. Available at https://icct.nl/publication/the-prosecution-of-foreign-fighters- under-international-humanitarian-law-misconceptions-and-opportunities/

RENARD, T., and COOLSAET, R. (2018), 'From the Kingdom to the Caliphate and Back: Returnees in Belgium', in Returnees: Who Are They, Why Are They (not) Coming Back and How Should We Deal with Them? Assessing Policies on Returning Foreign Terrorist Fighters in Belgium, Germany and the Netherlands, T. Renard and R. Coolsaet (eds.), Egmont Paper 101 (February 2018), pp. 19 ff..

SAUL, H. (2016), 'Amal Clooney Delivers Damning Speech to the UN Over Failure to Stop ISIS 'Genocide'': 'I am Ashamed'', The Independent, September 17, 2016. Available at https://www.independent.co.uk/news/people/amal-clooney-delivers- damning-speech-to-the-un-over-isis-genocide-i-wish-i-could-say-im-proud-to- be-a7313551.html.

SEGURA SERRANO, A., (2019), "National Measures Implementing United Nations Resolutions on Foreign Fighters", in Jihadism, Foreign Fighters and Radicalization in the EU. Legal, Functional and Psychosocial Responses, Marrero Rocha, I. and Trujillo Mendoza, H.M., (eds.), London and New York: Routledge, pp. 148-166. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429468506-9

SHEPHARD, M. (2017), '22-year-old Montreal Woman Escapes Daesh with Infant Daughters Three Years after Travelling to Syria', November 27, 2017. Available at https://www.thestar.com/news/world/2017/11/27/22-year-old-montreal-woman- escapes-daesh-with-infant-daughters-three-years-after-travelling-to-syria.html

SMITH, A. (2014), 'Iraqi Vice-president on Sunni Oppression, Nouri Al-Maliki and Sectarian Division ', Middle East Monitor, 28 August 2014. Available at https://www. middleeastmonitor.com/20140828-iraqi-vice-president-on-sunni-oppression- nouri-al-maliki-and-sectarian-division/

SOUFAN GROUP:

- (2014) Foreign Fighters in Syria.

- (2015) Foreign Fighters; An Updated Assessment of the Flow of Foreign Fighters into Syria and Iraq.

- (2017) Beyond the Caliphate: Foreign Fighters and the Threat of Returnees.

TRIAL INTERNATIONAL, Universal Jurisdiction Annual Review, 2020. Available at https://trialinternational.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/TRIAL-International_ UJAR-2020_DIGITAL.pdf

UK, Royal Courts of Justice, Government of Rwanda v. Nteziryayo and others. Available at https://www.judiciary.uk/judgments/rwanda-v-nteziryayo-and-others/

UN ANALYTICAL SUPPORT AND SANCTIONS MONITORING TEAM SUBMITTED PURSUANT TO RESOLUTION 2368 (2017) CONCERNING ISIL (DA'ESH), AL-QAIDA AND ASSOCIATED INDIVIDUALS AND ENTITIES:

- (2017), Twenty-first report, Doc. S/2018/14/Rev.1. https://doi.org/10.1002/mmr.31019

- (2018), Twenty-second report, Doc. S/2018/705.

UNAMI/OHCHR:

- (2014), Report on the Death Penalty in Iraq Baghdad. Available at https://www. ohchr.org/Documents/Countries/IQ/UNAMI_HRO_DP_1Oct2014.pdf

- (2017), Report on the Protection of Civilians in the Context of the Ninewa Operations and the Retaking of Mosul City, 17 October 2016 - 10 July 2017; November 2017. Available at http://www.uniraq.org/images/factsheets_reports/ Mosul_report%2017Oct2016-10Jul201731%20October_2017.pdf

- (2018), 'Unearthing Atrocities: Mass Graves in Territory Formerly Controlled by ISIL', 6 November 2018, p. 16, para. 9. Available at https://www.ohchr.org/ Documents/Countries/IQ/UNAMI_Report_on_Mass_Graves4Nov2018_EN.pdf

- (2020), Human Rights in the Administration of Justice in Iraq: Trials under the Antiterrorism Laws and Implications for Justice, Accountability and Social Cohesion in the Aftermath of ISIL. Available at UNAMIS's website: https:// www.uniraq.org/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&layout= category&task=category&id=164&Itemid=650&lang=en.

UN GENERAL ASSEMBLY

Resolution (2016), Doc. A/RES/71/248. UN HUMAN RIGHTS COUNCIL

- (2011), Doc. A/HRC/S-171.

- (2015), Doc. A/HRC/S-24.

- (2017), Doc. A/HRC/36/31.

- (2018), Doc. A/HRC/38/44/Add.1.

- (2018), Doc. A/HRC/39/L.22.

UNITED NATIONS INVESTIGATIVE TEAM TO PROMOTE ACCOUNTABILITY FOR CRIMES COMMITTED BY DA'ESH/ISLAMIC STATE IN IRAQ AND THE LEVANT (UNITAD)

- (2018) Terms of Reference of the Investigative Team to Support Domestic Efforts to Hold ISIL (Da'esh) Accountable of Acts that May Amount to War Crimes ÿ Crimes against Humanity and Genocide Committed in Iraq, established pursuant to Security Council resolution 2379.

- (November 2018), First Report of the Special Adviser and Head of the UNITAD, Doc. S/2018/1031.

- (May 2019), Second Report of the Special Adviser and Head of the UNITAD; Doc. S/2019/407.

- (November 2019), Third Report of the Special Adviser and Head of the UNITAD, Doc. S/2019/878.

- (May 2020), Fourth Report of the Special Adviser and Head of the UNITAD; Doc. S/2020/386.

- (November 2020), Fifth Report of the Special Adviser and Head of the UNITAD, Doc. S/2020/1107.

UN SECRETARY GENERAL:

- (2019), Eighth Report of the Secretary-General on the Threat Posed by ISIL (Da'esh) to International Peace and Security and the Range of United Nations Efforts in Support of Member States in Countering the Threat, Doc. S/2019/103.

- (2020), Eleventh Report of the Secretary-General on the Threat Posed by ISIL (Da'esh) to International Peace and Security and the Range of United Nations Efforts in Support of Member States in Countering the Threat, Doc. S/2020/774.

UN SECURITY COUNCIL, Letter dated 14 August 2017 from the Chargé d'affaires a.i. of the Permanent Mission of Iraq to the United Nations addressed to the President of the Security Council, S/2017/710.

UN SECURITY COUNCIL, Resolutions:

- (2001), Doc. S/RES/1373.

- (2014), Doc. S/RES/2170.

- (2014), Doc. S/RES/2178.

- (2017), Doc. S/RES/2379.

- (2017), Doc. S/RES/2396.

- (2018), Doc. S/RES/2421.

UN SECURITY COUNCIL, Counter-Terrorism Committee (2015), Guiding Principles on Foreign Terrorist Fighters, Doc. S/2015/939.

UN SECURITY COUNCIL, Counter-Terrorism Committee (2018), Addendum to the Guiding Principles on Foreign Terrorist Fighters, Doc. S/2018/1177.

UN SPECIAL RAPPORTEUR ON EXTRAJUDICIAL, SUMMARY OR ARBITRARY EXECUTIONS:

- (2017), 'End of Visit Statement of the Special Rapporteur on Extrajudicial, Summary or Arbitrary Executions on Her Visit to Iraq', Baghdad, Iraq, 24 November 2017. Available at https://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/ DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=22452&LangID=E

- (2018), Report on Her Mission to Iraq, UN. Doc. A/HRC/38/44/Add.1.

UN SPECIAL RAPPORTEUR ON THE HUMAN RIGHTS OF INTERNALLY DISPLACED

PERSONS (2020), Report on its Visit to Iraq, A/HRC/44/41/Add.1 (2020), par. 70.

VAN GINKEL, B., and MINKS, S. (2018), 'Addressing the Challenge of Returnees: Threat Perceptions, Policies and Practices in the Netherlands', in Returnees: Who Are They, Why Are They (not) Coming Back and How Should We Deal with Them? Assessing Policies on Returning Foreign Terrorist Fighters in Belgium, Germany and the Netherlands, T. Renard and R. Coolsaet (eds.), Egmont Paper 101 (February 2018), pp. 55 ff.

VAN SCHAACK, B. (2018), 'The Iraq Investigative Team and Prospects, for Justice for the Yazidi Genocide', 16 Journal of International Criminal Justice. Available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3099932 https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3099932

VAN SCHAACK, B. (2018), 'UN Releases Guidelines for Team Investigating ISIS Crimes in Iraq. Death Penalty Debate Dodged', February 19, 2018, Just Security. Available at https://www.justsecurity.org/52628/iraqi-investigative-team-terms- reference-released-death-penalty-debate-dodged/

VAN WILGENBURG, W. (2019), 'Judge: Belgium Should Return IS-children Immediately', Kurdistan 24, December 26, 2018. Available at http://www. kurdistan24.net/en/news/1654bb2d-679d-439b-94c6-7122faff4456

ZAKERHOSSEIN, M.H. (2016),'To Bury a Situation Alive - A Critical Reading of the ICC Prosecutor's Statement on the ISIS Situation', International Criminal Law Review, Vol. 16, pp. 613 ff. https://doi.org/10.1163/15718123-01604007