Transitional Justice, Victims and Human Rights in the Light of International Law and the Inter-American System of Human Rights

Authors

  • Florabel Quispe Remón Universidad Carlos III de Madrid

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v17.6440

Keywords:

Transitional justice, human rights, inter-American court, truth, victims

Abstract

The article begins by analyzing the origin and evolution of the concept "transitional justice", determining its characteristics, the context in which it was born and developed, as well as the role of the State in this process. Then it focuses attention on analyzing the development of this figure in the jurisprudence of the Inter-American Human Rights System, through the work that the Inter-American Court has been carrying out since its operation, interpreting in a broad way and always pro homini, the American Convention of Human Rights. Throughout its years of operation, it has ruled on the State’s obligation to protect and guarantee human rights and to carry out the pertinent investigations in the event of their violation; as well as the recognition of the status of victims to the victims’ families and their pronouncement of the right to the truth, not as an autonomous human right, but rather as a right of the victims and their next of kin. Undoubtedly, these are aspects that have gone beyond the American Convention.

References

CORTÉS RODAS, F., 2007. Los derechos de las víctimas de la violencia política a la verdad, la reparación y la justicia. Reflexiones sobre cuatro casos en América latina. Estudios Políticos, Issue 31.

DE GRIEFF, P., 2011. Algunas reflexiones acerca del desarrollo de la Justicia Transicional. Anuarios de Derechos Hmanos de la Universidad de Chile, Issue 7, pp. 17–39. https://doi.org/10.5354/0718-2058.2011.16994

DE GRIEFF, P., 2012. Theorizing Transitional Justice. In: M. Williams, R. Nagy & J. Elster, eds. Transitional Justice. New York: New York University Press, pp. 31–77. https://doi.org/10.18574/nyu/9780814794661.003.0002

DORADO, J., 2015. Justicia transcional. Eunomía Revista en Cultura de la Legalidad, Issue 8.

GUEMBE, M. J. & OLEA, H., 2006. No justice, no peace: Discussion of a legal framework regarding the demobilization of non-state armed groups in Colombia. In: N. Roht-Arriaza & J. Mariezcurrena, eds. Transitional Justice in the Twenty-First Century. Beyond Truth versus Justice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 120–142. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511617911.007

HAYNER, P., 2006. Comisiones de la Verdad: resumen esquemático. International Review of the Cross Red, Issue 862, pp. 1–18.

HAYNER, P., 2008. Verdades innombrables: El reto de las Comisiones de la Verdad. Ciudad de México: Fondo de Cultura Económica.

HUNTINGTON, S., 1994. La tercera ola, la democratización a finales del siglo XX. Barcelona: Paidós.

I/A Court HR, 1988. Caso Velásquez Rodríguez vs. Honduras, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 1997. Caso Castillo Páez vs. Perú, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 1998. Caso Blake vs. Guatemala, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 1999. Caso “Niños de la calle” (Villagrán Morale y otros) vs. Guatemala, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2000a. Caso Durand y Ugarte vs. Perú, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2000b. Caso Bámaca Velásquez vs. Guatemala, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2002. Caso Trujillo Oroza vs. Bolivia, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2003a. Caso Myrna Mack Chang vs. Guatemala, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2003b. Caso Bulacio vs. Argentina, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2003c. Caso Juan Humberto Sánchez vs. Honduras, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2004a. Caso 19 Comerciantes vs. Colombia, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2004b. Casso Molina Theissen vs. Guatemala, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2004c. Caso Hermanos Gómez Paquiyauri vs. Perú, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2004d. Caso Tibi vs. Ecuador, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2004e. Caso Masacre Plan de Sánchez vs. Guatemala, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2004f. Caso Carpio Nicolle vs. Guatemala, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2005a. Caso Masacre de Mapiripán vs. Colombia, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2005b. Caso Blanco Romero y otros vs. Venezuela, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2005c. Caso Hermanas Serrano Cruz vs. El Salvador, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2006a. Caso Almonacid Arellano vs. Chile, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2006b. Caso Goiburú vs. Paraguay, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2006c. Caso Masacre de Pueblo Bello vs. Colombia, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2006d. Caso Penal Castro Castro vs. Perú, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2007. Caso Masacre de la Rochela vs. Colombia, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2008a. Caso Gonzáles y Otras vs. Colombia, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2008b. Caso Heliodoro Portugal vs. Panamá, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2008c. Caso Valle Jaramillo y Otros vs. Colombia, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2009. Caso Anzualdo Castro vs. Perú, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2010. Caso Gomes Lund y otros (“Guerrilha do Araguaja) vs. Brasil, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2011a. Caso Barbini Duarte y otros vs. Uruguay, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2011b. Caso Gelman vs. Uruguay, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2012a. Caso Masacre de El Mozote y lugares aledaños vs. El Salvador, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2012b. Caso Gudiel Álvarez y otros (“Diario Militar”) vs. Guatemala, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2012c. Caso Masacre de Río Negro vs. Guatemala, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2012d. Caso Nadage Dorzema y otros vs. República Dominicana, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2014. Caso Rodríguez Vera y otros (Desaparecidos del Palacio de Justicia) vs. Colombia, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2015. Caso Comunidad Campesina de Santa Bárbara vs. Perú, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2020a. Caso Azul Rojas Marín y Otra vs. Perú, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

I/A Court HR, 2020b. Caso Comunidades indígenas miembros de la Asociación Lhaka Honhat (Nuestra Tierra) vs. Argentina, San José de Costa Rica: I/A Court HR.

KASAPAS, G., 2008. An introduccion to the concept of transitional justice: Wester Balcans and UE conditional. UNISION Disscusion Papers, Issue 18, pp. 59–76.

MÉNDEZ, J., 1997. Accountability for Past Abuses. Human Rights Quarterly, 19(2), pp. 255–282. https://doi.org/10.1353/hrq.1997.0018

NAQVI, P., 2006. El derecho a la verdad en el derecho internacional: ¿ficción o realidad?. International Review of the Red Cross, Issue 862.

O’DONNELLL, G. & SCHEMITTER, P., 2003 Spring. Transitions from authoritarian rule: tentative cinclusions about uncertain democracies IN Transitional Justice Geneology. Harvard Human Rights Journal, Volume 16, p. 69.

PAIGE, A., 2009. How "Transitions" Reshaped Human Rights: A conceptual history of Transitionl Justice. Human Rights Quaterly, 31(2), pp. 321–376. https://doi.org/10.1353/hrq.0.0069

PION-BERLIN, D., 1995. To prosecute or to pardon? Humans Right Decision in the Latin Amercican Souther Cone. In: N. Kritz, ed. Transitional Justice. Volumen I General consideration. Washington DC: United States Institute of Peace Press, pp. 82–103.

QUISPE REMÓN, F., 2010. El debido proceso en el derecho internacional y en el sitema interamericano. Valencia: Tirant lo Blanch.

QUISPE REMÓN, F., 2019. Los derecho humanos en el sistema interamericano. Valencia: Tirant lo Blanch.

ROHT-ARRIAZA, N., 2006. The new landscape of transitional justice. In: N. Roht-Arriaza & J. Mariezcurrena, eds. Transitional Justice in the Twenty-First Century. Beyond Truth versus Justice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 1–16. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511617911.001

SCHABAS, W., 2006. The Sierra Leona Truth and Reconcilation Commission. In: N. Roht-Arriaza & J. Mariezcurrena, eds. Transitional Justice in the Twenty-First Century. Beyond Truth versus Justice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 21–42. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511617911.003

SERSALE DI CERISANO, F., 2013. Justicia transicional en las Américas. El impacto del Sitema Interamericano. Revista IIDH, Issue 57, pp. 115–136.

SIKKINK, K. & WALLING, B., 2006. Argentina’s contribution to global trends in transitional justice. In: N. Roht-Arriaza & J. Mariezcurrena, eds. Transitional Justice in the Twenty-First Century. Beyond Truth versus Justice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 301–324. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511617911.015

SMITH, P., 2009. La democratización em América Latina (traducción de Carmen Martínrz Gimeno). Madrid: Marcial Pons. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctv10rrb5z

TEITEL, R., 2000. Transitional Justice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

TEITEL, R., 2003. Transitional Justice Geneology. Harvard Human Rights Journal, Volume 16, pp. 69–94.

UN, General Secretariat, 2004. Informe del Secretario General al Consejo de Seguridad, S/2004/616, Nueva York: s.n.

UN, Human Right Committe, 1992. Observacion General Nº 20, 44 período de sesiones, Ginebra: s.n.

WEBER, J. (2012). Forms of Transitional Justice. In: Transitional Justice. New York: New York University Press.

WILLIAMS, M., NAGY, R. & ELSTER, J., 2012. Transitional Justice. New York: New York University Press.

ZALAQUETT, P., 1995. Confronting human rights violations commited by former goverments: principles and political constraints. In: N. Kritz, ed. Transitional Justice. Volumen I General Considerations. Washington DC: United States Institute of Peace Press, pp. 3–31.

Published

2021-12-17

How to Cite

Quispe Remón, F. (2021). Transitional Justice, Victims and Human Rights in the Light of International Law and the Inter-American System of Human Rights. The Age of Human Rights Journal, (17), 300–327. https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v17.6440

Issue

Section

ARTICLES