The Persisting Menace of Child Marriage: An Account of Non-Legal Factors Contributing to Ineffectiveness of Legal Frameworks

Sanya  Darakhshan Kishwar

doi:10.17561/tahrj.v19.7228

Authors

Sanya Darakhshan Kishwar O.P. Jindal Global University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v19.7228

Keywords:

child marriage, forced marriage, armed conflict, child rights

Abstract

Child marriage is an ever-persisting human rights issue that has been addressed multiple times. However, despite the existing international frameworks and theoretical deliberation, the practice still continues to thrive across the globe. This presents suitable ground for a review of the causes of child marriage. This paper reviews such causes in two parts, the first being a review of the existing international framework, followed by a review of factors that lead to child marriage. Additionally, the paper attempts at presenting recommendations to inhibit the causal factors.

References

Primary Sources

International Treaty Law

Convention on Consent to Marriage, Minimum Age for Marriage and Registration of Marriages, [1962] GA Res. 1763 A (XVII) (Nov. 7, 1962)

Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women [1979] 1249 UNTS 13

Convention on the Rights of the Child [1989] 157 UNTS 3

International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights [1966] 999 UNTS 17

International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights [1966] 993 UNTS 3

Universal Declaration of Human Rights, [1948], GA Res. 217 A (III) UN Doc. A/810

Regional Treaty Law

Protocol to the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights on the Rights of Women in Africa, 2003/Maputo Protocol

South African Development Community’s Protocol on Gender and Development, 2008/SADC Protocol

The African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child, 1990

National Constitutions

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania, 1977

Constitution of the Republic of Zimbabwe Amendment (No. 20), 2013

National Laws

Cuba

The Cuban Family Code,

India

Indian Majority Act, 1875, Act No. 9 of 1875

The Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006, Act No. 6 of 2007

The Prohibition of Child Marriage (Amendment) Bill, 2021

Iran

The Civil Code of the Islamic Republic of Iran, 23 May 1928

South Africa

Children’s Act, 2005, Act No.38 of 2005

Tanzania

Law of Marriage Act, 1971, Act No. 5 of 1971

Yemen

Yemen’s Personal Status Act No. 20 of 1992

Zimbabwe

Marriage Act, Chapter 5:11, 1964

Zimbabwe: Customary Marriages Act, Chapter 5:07, 1951

International Case Laws

International Criminal Court [ICC]

Prosecutor v Dominic Ongwen, [2016] Decision on the confirmation of charges, ICC-02/04-01/15 (Ongwen, 2016)

Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia [ECCC]

Closing Order, Nuon Chea, Ieng Sary, Ieng Thirith, and Khieu Samphan, [2010] Case File No. 002/19-09-2007-ECCC-OCIJ, OCIJ (Nuon Chea at al., 2010)

The Special Court for Sierra Leone [SCSL]

Prosecutor v Alex Tamba Brima et al., [2007] SCSL-2004-16-T, Trial Chamber Judgment, Partly Dissenting Opinion of Justice Doherty on Count 7- sexual slavery, and Count 8 -‘forced marriage’ (Brima et al., 2007)

Prosecutor v Alex Tamba Brima et al., [2008] SCSL-2004-16-A, Appeals Chamber Judgment (Brima et al., 2008)

Prosecutor v Charles Ghankay Taylor, [2012] SCSL-03-01-T, Trial Judgment (Taylor, 2012)

European Court of Human Rights [ECtHR]

Boso v Italy, App. no. 50490/99, 5 September 2002

Centre for Legal Resources on behalf of Valentin Câmpeanu v. Romania, App. no. 47848/08, 14 July 2014

Emin and Others v. Cyprus, Greece and the United Kingdom (dec.), App. nos. 59623/08 and 6 other apps., 3 June 2010

Hirsi Jamaa and Others v. Italy, App. no. 27765/09, 23 February 2012

Ilias And Ahmed v. Hungary, App. no. 47287/15, 14 March 2017

Khan v. France, App. no. 12267/16, 28 February 2019

L.C.B. v. the United Kingdom, App. no. 23413/94, 9 June 1998

M.A. v. France, App. no. 9373/15, 1 February 2018

Mubilanzila Mayeka and Kaniki Mitunga v. Belgium, App. no. 13178/03, 12 October 2006

Muskhadzhiyeva and Others v. Belgium, No. 41442/07, 19 January 2010

N.D. and N.T. v. Spain, App. nos. 8675/15 and 8697/15, 13 February 2020

Popov v. France, App. Nos. 39472/07 and 39474/07, 19 January 2012

Rahimi v. Greece, App. no. 8687/08, 5 April 2011

Rantsev v. Cyprus and Russia, App. no. 25965/04, 7 January 2010

Salah Sheekh v. the Netherlands, App. no. 1948/04, 11 January 2007

Z. H. and R. H. v Switzerland, App. no. 60119/12, 8 December 2015

National Case Laws

Tanzania

Attorney General v. Rebeca Z Gyumi (Court of Appeal of the United Republic o/Tanzania, Civil Appeal No. 204 o/2017)

Rebeca Z Gyumi v. Attorney General (High Court of the United Republic of Tanzania; Tanzania Civil Cause No. 5 of 2016; Decided July 8, 2016).

Zimbabwe

Loveness Mudzuru & Ruvimbo Tsopodzi v. Minister of Justice and Parliamentary Affairs NO. & Others (Constitutional Court o/Zimbabwe, Constitutional Application No. 79/14, Judgment No. CCZ 12/2015)

Secondary Sources

International Resolutions

UNGA (2018). United Nations General Assembly, ‘Intensifying efforts to end obstetric fistula within a generation ─Report of the Secretary-General’ (31 July 2018) UN Doc A/73/285.

UNGA (2016). United Nations General Assembly, ‘Child, early and forced marriage Report of the Secretary-General’ (29 July 2016) UN Doc A/71/253.

UNGA (Oct. 2015). United Nations General Assembly, ‘Transforming our world: the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development’ (21 October 2015) UN Doc A/RES/70/1.

UNGA (Jan.2015). United Nations General Assembly, ’Child, early and forced marriage’ (22 January 2015) UN Doc A/RES/69/156.

UNGA (2012). United Nations General Assembly, ‘Human Rights Council Report of the Special Rapporteur on contemporary forms of slavery, including its causes and consequences’ (10 July 2012) UN Doc A/HRC/21/41.

Regional Resolutions

Council of Europe Parliamentary Assembly, ‘Forced Marriages and Child Marriages’, (5 October 2005) Resolution 1468 (2005).

Reports

CEDAW/CRC (2015). Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) and Committee on the Rights of the Child (CRC), ‘Joint general recommendation/general comment No. 31 of the Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women and No. 18 of the Committee on the Rights of the Child on harmful practices’ (4 November 2014) UN Doc CEDAW/C/GC/31-CRC/C/GC/18.

CRC (2020). Combined third to sixth periodic reports submitted by Cuba under article 44 of the Convention, due in 2017 (27 January 2020) UN Doc CRC/C/CUB/3-6

CRC (2008). Committee on the Rights of the Child, ‘Concluding Observations: Eritrea’ (23 June 2008) UN Doc CRC/C/ERI/CO/3.

CRC (2000). Committee on the Rights of the Child, ‘Summary Record of the 621st Meeting’ (11 July 2000) UN Doc CRC/C/ SR.621.

CRC (GC 14, 2013). Committee on the Rights of the Child, ‘General Comment No. 14 (2013) on the Rights of the Child to have his or her best interests taken as a primary consideration (art. 3, para. 1) (29 May 2013) UN Doc CRC/C/GC/14.

CRC (GC 4, 2003). Committee on the Rights of the Child, ‘General Comment No. 4 on Adolescent Health and Development in the Context of the CRC’ (1 July 2003) UN Doc CRC/GC/2003/4.

UNHRC (2021). Human Rights Council, Forty-eighth session, ‘Promotion and protection of all human rights, civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights, including the right to development’ (7 October 2021) UN Doc A/HRC/48/L.7/Rev.1.

UNHRC (2019). United Nations Human Rights Council, ‘Child, early and forced marriage in humanitarian settings’ (26 April 2019) UN Doc A/HRC/41/19.

UNHRC (2017). 35th session Expert workshop on the impact of existing strategies and initiatives to address child, early and forced marriage, 24 March 2017, UN Doc A/HRC/35/5.

UNHRC (2015). United Nations Human Rights Council, ‘Strengthening efforts to prevent and eliminate child, early and forced marriage: challenges, achievements, best practices and implementation gaps’ (25 September 2013) UN Doc A/HRC/RES/29/8.

UNHRC (2014). United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, ‘Preventing and eliminating child, early and forced marriage: Report of the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights’ (2 April 2014) UN Doc A/HRC/26/22.

UNICEF (May, 2022). ‘Child Marriage’, United Nations Children’s Fund. May 2022. Available at https://data.unicef.org/topic/child-protection/child-marriage/

UNICEF (Jun. 2021). ‘Harmful Practices’, United Nations Children’s Fund. June 2021. Available at https://www.unicef.org/protection/harmful-practices.

UNICEF (Mar.2021). ‘10 million additional girls at risk of child marriage due to COVID-19’, United Nations Children’s Fund, March 7, 2021. Available at https://www.unicef.org/press-releases/10-million-additional-girls-risk-child-marriage-due-covid-19.

UNICEF (2017). ‘27 million children out of school in conflict zones’, United Nations Children’s Fund, September 18, 2017. Available at https://www.unicef.org/press-releases/27-million-children-out-school-conflict-zones.

UNICEF (2014). ‘Ending Child Marriage: Progress and Prospects’. United Nations Children’s Fund July, 2014. Available at https://data.unicef.org/resources/ending-child-marriage-progress-and-prospects/

UNICEF (2005). ‘Early Marriage: A Harmful Traditional Practice’, United Nations Children’s Fund, October 2015. Available at https://data.unicef.org/resources/early-marriage-a-traditional-harmful-practice-a-statistical-exploration/

National Reports

(NFHS-5). ‘National Family Health Survey – 5 (2019-21)’, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, India. Available at http://rchiips.org/nfhs/factsheet_NFHS-5.shtml

Country Reports on South Sudan (2019). ‘Country Report, Human Rights Practices: South Sudan’, US Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labour. Available at https://www.state.gov/reports/2019-country-reports-on-human-rights-practices/south-sudan/2019

Books and Journal Articles

AL-DAWOODY, A., and MURPHY, V. (2019). “International humanitarian law, Islamic law and the protection of children in armed conflict”, International Review of Red Cross, Vol. 101, Number 911, pp. 551, 559–60. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1816383119000560.

ARTHUR, M. et al. (2018). “Child Marriage Laws around the World: Minimum Marriage Age, Legal Exceptions, and Gender Disparities”, Journal of Women, Politics and Policy, Vol. 39, Number 1, pp. 51, 60. https://doi.org/10.1080/1554477X.2017.1375786.

AVALOS, L. et al. (2015). “Ending Female Genital Mutilation & Child Marriage in Tanzania”, Fordham Int’l L Journal, Vol. 38, p. 639.

BAKHACHE, N. et al. (2017) “Global Health Action Implementation of a SenseMaker® research project among Syrian refugees in Lebanon Implementation of a SenseMaker® research project among Syrian refugees in Lebanon”, Glob Health Action, Vol. 10. https://doi.org/10.1080/16549716.2017.1362792

BARTELS S, et al. (2018). ‘Making Sense of Child, Early and Forced Marriage among Syrian Refugee Girls: A Mixed Methods Study in Lebanon’, BMJ Global Health, Vol. 3, Number 1, p. 1. https://doi.org.10.1136/bmjgh-2017-000509.

BENTLEY, K. (2005). “Can there be any universal children’s rights?”, The International Journal of Human Rights, Vol. 9, Number 1, pp. 107–123. https://doi.org/10.1080/13642980500032370.

BLAKEMORE, S., and CHOUDHURY, S. (2006). “Development of the Adolescent Brain: Implications for Executive Function and Social Cognition”, Child Psychology and Psychiatry, Vol. 47, Number 3-4, pp. 296–312. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-7610.2006.01611.x.

BOYDEN J., and DE BERRY, J. (2004). Children and Youth on the Front Line: Ethnography, Armed Conflict and Displacement, Berghahn Books, p. 256.

CARLSON, K. and MAZURANA, D. (2008). Forced Marriage within the Lord’s Resistance Army, Uganda, Feinstein International Center, p. 4.

COOK, R. et al. (2004). “Obstetric Fisticula: The Challenge to Human Rights”, International Journal of Gynecology and Obstetrics, Vol. 87, pp. 72–77. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijgo.2004.07.005.

CORNO, L. and VOENA, A. (2021). ‘Selling daughters: Child Marriage, Income Shocks and the Bride Price Tradition’, Working Paper. Available at https://avoena.people.stanford.edu/sites/g/files/sbiybj24271/files/media/file/cornovoena_feb2021_final.pdf.

DAGNE, H. G. (1994). “Early marriage in Northern Ethiopia”, Reproductive Health Matters, Vol. 2, pp. 35–38. https://doi.org/10.1016/0968-8080(94)90006-X.

DAMON, A. (2013). ‘No sanctuary for Syria’s female refugees’, CNN, June 26, 2013. Available at https://edition.cnn.com/2013/06/26/world/meast/syria-refugees-child-brides/index.html

DIMITRY, L. (2011). “A Systematic Review on the Mental Health of Children and Adolescents in Areas of Armed Conflict in the Middle East”, Child: Care Health and Development, Vol. 38, pp. 153, 157. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2214.2011.01246.x

DOUGLAS, G. (1997). ‘The Significance of International Law for the Development of Family Law in England and Wales’, in Essays for P.M. Bromley – Family Law Towards the Millennium, Butterworths, p. 89.

EBOE-OSUJI, C. (2012) International law and sexual violence in armed conflicts, Brill, p. 91.

EL-ARAB, R., and SAGBAKKEN, M. (2019). “Child marriage of female Syrian refugees in Jordan and Lebanon: A Literature Review”, BMJ Global Health Action, Vol. 12, pp. 1, 7. https://doi.org/10.1080/16549716.2019.1585709

ERIKSSON, M. (1992). ‘Article 16’, in The Universal Declaration of Human Rights: A Commentary, The Scandinavian University Press, p. 243.

FAHIMI, F., and IBRAHIM S. (2013). Ending Child Marriage in the Arab Region, Population Reference Bureau, p. 2.

GAFFNEY-RHYS, R. (2011). “International law as an instrument to combat child marriage”, IJHR, Volume 15, Number 3, p. 359. https://doi.org/10.1080/13642980903315398

HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH (2012). ‘The Armed Conflict in Sierra Leone’, Human Rights Watch, April 11, 2012. Available at https://www.hrw.org/news/2012/04/11/armed-conflict-sierra-leone.

HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH (2016). ‘Lebanon: Syrian Women at Risk of Sex Trafficking’, Human Rights Watch, July 28, 2016. Available at https://www.hrw.org/news/2016/07/28/lebanon-syrian-women-risk-sex-trafficking.

HUNERSEN, K. et al. (2021). “Child Marriage in Yemen: A Mixed Methods Study in Ongoing Conflict and Displacement”, J Refugee Stud, Volume 34, Number 4, pp. 4551–4571. https://doi.org/10.1093/jrs/feaa144.

JAIN, N. (2008). “Forced Marriage as a Crime against Humanity, Problems of Definition and Prosecution”, J. Int. Criminal Justice, Vol. 6, Number 4, p. 1013. https://doi.org/10.1093/jicj/mqn064.

JAMOBO, T. (2012). “A Discourse on the Developmental Effects of Child Marriage”, African Journal of Social Sciences, Vol. 2, Number 3, p. 138. doi: 10.1.1.301.272.

JENSEN, R., and THORNTON, R. (2003). “Early Female Marriage in the Developing World”, Marriage, Vol. 11, pp. 9, 19. https://doi.org/10.1080/741954311.

KARIMAKWENDA, N. (2021). “Rethinking ukuthwala, the South African ‘bride abduction’ custom”, 12 Sept 2021, 9.18am BST, The Conversation. Available at https://theconversation.com/rethinking-ukuthwala-the-south-african-bride-abduction-custom-165496

KIDMAN, R. (2017). “Child Marriage and Intimate Partner Violence: A Comparative Study of 34 Countries”, International Journal of Epidemiology, Vol. 46, Number 2, pp. 662–63. doi: 10.1093/ije/dyw225.

LEE-RIFE, S. et al. (2012). “What Works to Prevent Child Marriage: A Review of the Evidence”, Studies in Family Planning, Vol. 43, Number 4, pp. 292, 293. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1728-4465.2012.00327.x.

LEMMON, G. (2014). Fragile states, fragile lives: Child marriage amid disaster and conflict: Working Paper, Council on Foreign Relations, pp. 7–8.

LEVINE, R. et al. (2008). Girls Count – A Global Investment and Action Agenda, Centre for Global Development, p. 44.

LISCHER, S. (2007). “Causes and Consequences of Conflict-Induced Displacement”, Civil Wars, Vol. 9, Number 2, p. 142. https://doi.org/10.1080/13698240701207302.

LOWE, N., and DOUGLAS, G. (2007). Bromley’s Family Law, Oxford University Press, p. 24.

MATHUR, S. et al. (2003). Too Young to Wed: The Lives, Rights, and Health of Young Married Girls, International Center for Research on Women, pp. 6–7.

MAZURANA, D. et al. (2019). “Child marriage in armed conflict”, International Review of Red Cross, Vol. 101, Number 911, pp. 575–77. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1816383120000156.

MCKAY, S., and MAZURANA, D. (2004). “Where Are the Girls? Girls in Fighting Forces in Northern Uganda, Sierra Leone and Mozambique: Their Lives after the War” Consortium on Gender Security and Human Rights.

MOSS, M. (2015). ‘Tara Moss Reports on the Rise of Child Brides in Syrian Refugee Camps’, TaraMoss, October 11, 2015. Available at https://taramoss.com/the-rise-of-the-syrian-child-bride/.

MOURTADA, R. et al. (2017). “A qualitative study exploring child marriage practices among Syrian conflict-affected populations In Lebanon”, Conflict and Health, Vol. 11, Number 27, pp. 53, 54. doi: 10.1186/s13031-017-0131-z.

NGUYEN, F. (2014). “Untangling Sex, Marriage, and Other Criminalities in Forced Marriage”, Goettingen Journal of International Criminal Law, Vol. 6, Number 1, pp. 13–45. https://doi.org/10.3249/1868-1581-6-1-nguyen.

NOUR, N. (2009). “Child Marriage: A Silent Health and Human Rights Issue”, Reviews in Obstetrics & Gynaecology, Vol. 2, Number 1, pp. 51, 54. PMID: 19399295.

NOVE, A. et al. (2014). “Maternal Mortality in Adolescents Compared with Women of Other Ages: Evidence from 144 Countries”, The Lancet Global Health, Vol. 2, Number 3, pp. 155–64. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2214-109X(13)70179-7.

OUATTARA, M. et al. (1998). “Forced marriage, forced sex: The perils of childhood for girls”, Gender and Development, Vol. 6, Number 3, pp. 27–30. https://doi.org/10.1080/741922829.

PARK, A. (2006). “Other inhumane acts: forced marriage, girl soldiers and the special court for Sierra Leone”, Social & Legal Studies, Vol. 15, Number 3, pp. 315, 322. https://doi.org/10.1177/0964663906066611.

PEREZNIETO, P. et al. (2017). Mitigating Threats to Girls’ Education in conflict-affected contexts: Current Practice, United Nations Girl’s Education Initiative, p. 18.

PUPAVAC, V. (2001). “Misanthropy without Borders: The International Children’s Rights Regime”, Disasters, Vol. 25, Number 2, pp. 95, 99. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-7717.00164.

RAJ, A. et al. (2009). “Prevalence of Child Marriage and its Effects on Fertility and Fertility Control Outcomes of Young Women in India: A Cross-sectional, Observational Study”, The Lancet, Vol. 373, Number 9678, p. 1883. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(09)60246-4.

RODGERS, M. et al. (2008). “Yemen: Nine-and ten-year-old girls forced into marriage, fight for divorce”, Off Our Backs, Vol. 38, Number 1, pp.5–6. https://doi.org/10.2307/20838904.

ROUPETZ, S. et al. (2020). “Continuum of sexual and gender-based violence risks among Syrian refugee women and girls in Lebanon”, BMC Women’s Health, Vol. 20, Number 176, pp. 2, 5. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12905-020-01009-2.

RUBIN, S. (2013). ‘Poor and Vulnerable, Syrian Refugee Families Push Girls into Early Marriage’, The Christian Science Monitor, December 6, 2013. Available at https://www.csmonitor.com/World/Middle-East/2013/1206/Poor-and-vulnerable-Syrian-refugee-families-push-girls-into-early-marriage.

SAHM (2017). The Society for Adolescent Health and Medicine, “Young Adult Health and Well-Being: A Position Statement of the Society for Adolescent Health and Medicine”, Journal of Adolescent Health, Vol. 60, p. 758.

SKIVENES, M., and SORSDAL, L. (2018). ‘The Child’s Best Interest Principle across Child Protection Jurisdictions’ in Human Rights in Child Protection, Macmillan, p. 63.

SPEAR, L. (2004). “The Adolescent Brain and Age-Related Behavioral Manifestations Neuroscience”, Biobehavioral Reviews, Vol. 24, Number 4, pp. 417–63. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0149-7634(00)00014-2.

STÖPPLER, M. (2019). ‘Puberty First Signs, Symptoms, Ages, and Stages in Girls and Boys’, MedicineNet, December 12, 2019. Available at https://www.medicinenet.com/puberty/article.htm.

STRC (2004 Vol 3A). ‘Sierra Leone, Truth & Reconciliation Commission Report, Witness to Truth: Report of the Sierra Leone Truth & Reconciliation Commission, Vol. 2’. Available at https://www.sierraleonetrc.org/index.php/view-the-final-report/download-table-of-contents.

STRC (2004 Vol 3A). ‘Sierra Leone, Truth & Reconciliation Commission Report, Witness to Truth: Report of the Sierra Leone Truth & Reconciliation Commission, Vol. 3A’. Available at https://www.sierraleonetrc.org/index.php/view-the-final-report/download-table-of-contents.

THOMPSON, S. (2020). ‘COVID-19’s Shadow Pandemic Driving Early Marriage’, Berkley Centre, July 29, 2020. Available at https://berkleycenter.georgetown.edu/posts/covid-19-s-shadow-pandemic-driving-early-marriage.

TITHILA, K. (2020). ‘Is Covid-19 pandemic leading to a rise in child marriage?’, Deccan Tribune, June 9, 2020. Available at https://archive.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/2020/07/09/parents-using-pandemic-as-opportunity-to-marry-off-underage-daughters.

TOBY, H. (2019). “South Sudan court rules against marriage of girl, 16, in landmark case”, Reuters (10 July, 2019). Available at https://www.reuters.com/article/us-southsudan-women-court-idUSKCN1U42CK.

UN WOMEN (2013). Inter-Agency Assessment of Gender-based Violence and Child Protection among Syrian Refugees in Jordan, with a Focus on Early Marriage, UN Women.

UNICEF Innocenti (2001). “Early Marriage Child Spouses”, Innocenti Digest, Vol. 6.

WORLD BANK (2011). World Development Report 2011: Conflict, Security, and Development, World Bank.

WUILBERCQ, E. (2020). ‘Hundreds of Ethiopian Girls Saved From Child Marriage Amid Coronavirus Lockdowns’, Global Citizen, May 16, 2020. Available at https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/ethiopian-girls-saved-from-child-marriage-covid-19/.

ZIPFEL, G. (2013). ‘Let us have a little fun”: The relationship between gender, violence, and sexuality in armed conflict situations’, RCCS Annual Review, Vol. 5. https://doi.org/10.4000/rccsar.469.