Law, Memory, and Silence: The Case of Anti-Communism Laws in Indonesia

Harison Citrawan; Ganesh Cintika Putri

doi:10.17561/tahrj.v22.8021

Authors

Harison Citrawan Penn State Dickinson Law
Ganesh Cintika Putri

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v22.8021

Keywords:

Anti-communist, Indonesia, Law, Memory, Silencing

Abstract

This article investigates the role of Indonesia’s Anti-Communism laws in shaping and shifting collective memory of past atrocities into an imperative history. These laws are to be understood as a set of rules enacted by the state to proscribe the existence of communism by criminalizing speech of any kind that disseminates the idea of Marxism, Leninism, and Communism. Based on our analysis of several judicial decisions and empirical evidence related to the creation of collective memory, we contend that the problem of the anti-communism laws is twofold. First, these laws show a conflict between law and history because they enable judicial practices to transform the judges into the arbiters of history. Second, these laws—in addition to other institutions, mechanisms and ultimately embedded ideas/norms—have been enabling a process of social silencing that infringes freedom of expression as they have moved away from punishing acts to punishing speech, writing and certain ways of being.

References

ARTHUR, P. (2016) ‘Notes from the Field: Global Indicators for Transitional Justice and Challenges in Measurement for Policy Actors’, Transitional Justice Review, 1(4), pp. 1–27. Available at: https://doi.org/10.5206/tjr.2016.1.4.9.

BADAN PEMBINAAN HUKUM NASIONAL (2018) Academic Paper of Penal Code Bills (Naskah Akademik RUU KUHP).

BAXTER, H. (1998) ‘Autopoiesis and the “relative autonomy” of law’, Cardozo Law Review, 19(6), pp. 1987–2090.

BEDNER, A. and Wiratraman, H.P. (2019) ‘The Administrative Courts: The Quest for Consistency’, in M. Crouch (ed.) The Politics of Courts in Indonesia: The Judicial Landscape and the Work of Dan S Lev. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 133–148.

BOURDIEU, P. (1987) ‘The Force of Law: Toward a Sociology of the Juridical Field’, Hastings Law Journal, 38(5), p. 805.

BUTT, S. and LINDSEY, T. (2018) Indonesian Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

CITRAWAN, H. (2018a) ‘From Grievance to Welfare: Reshaping the Identity of Past Gross Violation of Human Rights Victims in Indonesia’, Jurnal Masyarakat dan Budaya, 20(2), pp. 237–248. Available at: https://doi.org/10.14203/JMB.V20I2.571.

CITRAWAN, H. (2018b) ‘Melampaui hak asasi manusia: Agama, kekerasan dan kegagalan keadilan transisional Indonesia’, in A. Khanif and M.K. Wardaya (eds) Hak Asasi Manusia: Politik, Hukum dan Agama di Indonesia. LKIS, pp. 1–28.

COHEN, S. (2001) States of Denial: Knowing about Atrocities and Suffering. Cambridge: Polity Press.

COTTERREL, R. (2004) ‘Law in Social Theory and Social Theory in the Study of Law’, in A. Sarat (ed.) The Blackwell Companion to Law and Society. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, pp. 15–29. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470693650.

CRIBB, R. (2001) ‘Genocide in Indonesia, 1965–1966’, Journal of Genocide Research, 3(2), pp. 219–239.

DIPROSE, R., McRAE, D. and HADIZ, V.R. (2019) ‘ Two Decades of Reformasi in Indonesia: Its Illiberal Turn ’, Journal of Contemporary Asia, 00(00), pp. 1–22. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1080/00472336.2019.1637922.

DURKHEIM, E. (1995) The Elementary Forms of Religious Life (Translated by Karen E. Fields). New York: The Free Press.

EICKHOFF, M. et al. (2017) ‘The Memory Landscapes of “ 1965 ” in Semarang’, Journal of Genocide Research, 19(4), pp. 530–550. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1080/14623528.2017.1393945.

EICKHOFF, M., KLINKEN, G. VAN and ROBINSON, G. (2017) ‘1965 Today : Living with the Indonesian Massacres’, Journal of Genocide Research, 19(4), pp. 449–464. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1080/14623528.2017.1393931.

FAHRURODJI, A. and ZUHDI, S. (2023) ‘From Stalin to Khrushchev: The Dynamics of Soviet Union–Indonesia Relations, 1945–1964’, in M. Budianta and S. Tiwon (eds) Trajectories of Memory: Excavating the Past in Indonesia. Singapore: Springer Nature Singapore, pp. 151–167.

FAIZ, P.M. (2016) ‘The Protection of Civil and Political Rights by the Constitutional Court of Indonesia’, Indonesia Law Review, 6(2), p. 158. Available at: https://doi.org/10.15742/ilrev.v6n2.230.

FRONZA, E. (2018) Memory and Punishment: Historical Denialism, Free Speech and the Limits of Criminal Law, International Criminal Justice Series. The Hague: T.M.C Asser Press. Available at: http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0731129X.2000.9992088.

HALBWACHS, M. (1992) On Collective Memory. Edited by L.A. Coser. Chicago, London: The University of Chicago Press.

HATLEY, B. (2009) ‘Social reconciliation and community integration through theater’, in B. Brauchler (ed.) Reconciling Indonesia: Grassroots Agency for Peace, pp. 77–96.

HENDRIANTO, S. (2020) ‘Constitutionalized But Not Constitute: The Case of Right to Social Security in Indonesia’, Const. Rev., 6, p. 241.

HERYANTO, A. (1999) ‘Where Communism never dies: Violence, trauma and narration in the last Cold War capitalist authoritarian state’, International Journal of Cultural Studies, 2(2), pp. 147–177. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1177/136787799900200201.

HERYANTO, A. (2005) ‘State Terrorism and Political Identity in Indonesia: Fatally Belonging’, State Terrorism and Political Identity in Indonesia: Fatally Belonging, pp. 1–242. Available at: https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203099827.

HERYANTO, A. (2012) ‘Screening 1965 Violence’, in J. Ten Brink and J. Oppenheimer (eds) Killer Images: Documentary Films, Images and the Performance of Violence. New York: Columbia University Press, p. 224.

HUYSSEN, A. (2003) Present Pasts: Urban Palimpsets and the Politics of Memory. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

IKHWAN, H., YULIANTO, V.I. and PARAHITA, G.D. (2019) ‘The Contestation of Social Memory in the New Media : A Case Study of the 1965 Killings in Indonesia’, 12, pp. 3–16.

IRFANI, S., MUHARAM, R.S. and SUNARSO, S. (2022) ‘Keadilan Hak Asasi Manusia dalam Aksi Kamisan di Indonesia’, Jurnal HAM, 13(1).

JACOBS, J. (2010) Memorializing The Holocaust : Gender, Genocide and Collective Memory. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

JELIN, E. (2003) State Repression and the Labors of Memory. University of Minnesota Press.

LABANYI, J. (2009) ‘The languages of silence : historical memory , generational transmission and witnessing in contemporary Spain’, Journal of Romance Studies, 9(3), pp. 23–35. Available at: https://doi.org/10.3167/jrs.2009.090303.

LACEY, N. (2007) ‘Denial and responsibility’, in D. Downes et al. (eds) Crime, Social Control and Human Rights: From moral panics to states of denial - Essays in honour of Stanley Cohen. Devon, Oregon: Willan Publishing, pp. 255–269.

LAKSMANA, E.A. (2019) ‘Reshuffling the Deck? Military Corporatism, Promotional Logjams and Post-Authoritarian Civil-Military Relations in Indonesia’, Journal of Contemporary Asia, 00(00), pp. 1–31. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1080/00472336.2019.1613556.

LANGENOHL, A. (2008) ‘Memory in Post-Authoritarian Societies’, in A. Erll and A. Nünning (eds) Cultural Memory Studies: An International and Interdisciplinary Handbook. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.

LIS, M. (2018) ‘The History of Loss and the Loss of History: Papermoon Puppet Theatre Examines the Legacies of the 1965 Violence in Indonesia’, in K.E. Mcgregor (ed.) The Indonesian Genocide of 1965. Francis & Taylor, pp. 253–268. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-71455-4.

LOPEZ, R. (2015) ‘The (Re)Collection of Memory after Mass Atrocity and the Dilemma for Transitional Justice’, International Law and Politics, 47, p. 799.

LÖYTÖMÄKI, S. (2014) Law and the Politics of Memory: Confronting the Past. Oxford & New York: Routledge.

LUHMANN, N. (2004) Law as a social system. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

MATHER, L. (2013) ‘Law and Society’, in R.E. Goodin (ed.) The Oxford Handbook of Political Science. Oxford Handbooks Online, pp. 1–20. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199604456.013.0015.

McAULIFFE, P. (2013) Transitional Justice and Rule of Law Reconstruction: A Contentious Relationship. London & New York: Routledge. Available at: https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203771112.

McGREGOR, K.E. (2013) ‘Memory studies and human rights in Indonesia’, Asian Studies Review, 37(3), pp. 350–361.

McGREGOR, K.E. (2015) ‘Time , memory and historical justice : An introduction’. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1177/0961463X11431313.

McGREGOR, K.E. and Setiawan, K. (2019) ‘Shifting from International to “Indonesian” Justice Measures: Two Decades of Addressing Past Human Rights Violations’, Journal of Contemporary Asia, 49(5), pp. 837–861. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1080/00472336.2019.1584636.

McNAUGHTON, C. (2015) ‘Reading the mass violence in Indonesia 1965–1966 as a form of primitive accumulation’, Inter-Asia Cultural Studies, pp. 292–305. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1080/14649373.2015.1037086.

MEIER, R.F. (2019) ‘Deviance, Social Control, and Criminalization’, in M. Deflem (ed.) The Handbook of Social Control. Oxford: Wiley Blackwell, pp. 21–35.

MELVIN, J. (2018) The Army and the Indonesian Genocide: Mechanics of Mass Murder. New York: Routledge.

MILLER, S. (2018) ‘Zombie Anti-Communism? Democratization and the Demons of Suharto-Era Politics in Contemporary Indonesia’, in K. McGregor, J. Melvin, and A. Pohlman (eds) The Indonesian Genocide of 1965 Causes, Dynamics and Legacies. Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 287–310. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-71455-4.

MOON, C. (2007) ‘States of acknowledgement: the politics of memory, apology, and therapy’, in D. Downes et al. (eds) Crime, Social Control and Human Rights: From moral panics to states of denial - Essays in honour of Stanley Cohen. Oregon: Willan Publishing, pp. 314–329.

MUNSI, H. (2016) ‘Dari Masa Lalu ke Masa Kini: Memori Kolektif, Konstruksi Negara dan Normalisasi Anti-Komunis’, Jurnal Etnosia, 1(1), pp. 30–43.

OSIEL, M.J. (2017) Mass atrocity, collective memory and the law. Routledge.

PARENT, G. (2016) ‘Genocide Denial: Perpetuating Victimization and the Cycle of Violence in Bosnia and Herzegovina (BiH)’, Genocide Studies and Prevention, 10(2), pp. 38–58. Available at: https://doi.org/10.5038/1911-9933.10.2.1369.

PASUPATHI, M. and McLEAN, K.C. (2010) ‘How silence affects memory, self, and society: Foreword to the Special Issue’, Memory, 18(2), pp. 85–87.

PITALOKA, D. and DUTTA, MOHAN JYOTI (2019) ‘Embodied Memories and Spaces of Healing: Culturally-Centering Voices of the Survivors of 1965 Indonesian Mass Killings’, in M. J. Dutta and D.B. Zapata (eds) Communicating for Social Change: Meaning, Power, and Resistance. Singapore: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 333–357.

POSTEMA, G.J. (1982) ‘Coordination and Convention at the Foundations of Law’, The Journal of Legal Studies, 11(1), pp. 165–203.

POSTEMA, G.J. (1991) ‘On the Moral Presence of Our Past’, McGill Law Journal, 36(4), pp. 1153–1180.

POSTEMA, G.J. (2004) ‘Melody and Law’s Mindfulness of Time’, Ratio Juris, 17(2), pp. 203–226.

PRATIWI, C.S. (2021) ‘Rethinking the Constitutionality of Indonesia’s Flawed Anti-Blasphemy Law’, Const. Rev., 7, p. 273.

PUTRI, G.C. (2018) ‘Seni untuk damai: Upaya rekonsiliasi akar rumput pasca tragedi 1965’, Masyarakat Indonesia, 44(2), pp. 48–59.

RIGNEY, A. (2012) ‘Reconciliation and remembering : (how) does it work?’, Memory Studies, 5(3), pp. 251–258. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1177/1750698012440927.

SARAT, A. and KEARNS, T.R. (2005) ‘Writing History and Registering Memory in Legal Decisions and Legal Practices: An Introduction’, in A. Sarat and T.R. Kearns (eds) History, Memory, and the Law. The University of Michigan Press, pp. 1–24.

SAVELSBERG, J.J. and KING, R.D. (2007) ‘Law and Collective Memory’, Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 3(1), pp. 189–211. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.lawsocsci.3.081806.112757.

SAVELSBERG, J.J. and McELRATH, S. (2014) ‘Crime, Law, and Regime Change’, Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 10(1), pp. 259–279. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-lawsocsci-110413-030555.

SETIAWAN, K. (2018) ‘Between Law, Politics and Memory: Indonesia’s National Commission on Human Rights and the Quest for Justice for Past Human Rights Crimes’, Australian Journal of Asian Law, 19(1).

SETIAWAN, K. (2019) ‘The Human Rights Courts: Embedding Impunity’, in M. Crouch (ed.) The Politics of Court Reform: Judicial Change and Legal Culture in Indonesia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 287–310.

SUH, J. (2012) The politics of transitional justice in post-Suharto Indonesia. The Ohio State University.

SULISTIYANTO, P. (2007) ‘Politics of justice and reconciliation in post-Suharto Indonesia’, Journal of Contemporary Asia, 37(1), pp. 73–94.

THORNE, B. (2023) The Figure of the Witness in International Criminal Tribunals: Memory, Atrocities and Transitional Justice. Oxon & New York: Taylor & Francis.

TREVIÑO, A.J. (2019) ‘Law as Social Control’, in M. Deflem (ed.) The Handbook of Social Control. Oxford: Wiley Blackwell, pp. 36–49.

WAHID, A. (2018) ‘Counterrevolution in a Revolutionary Campus: How Did the “1965 Event” Affect an Indonesian Public University?’, The Indonesian Genocide of 1965: Causes, Dynamics and Legacies, p. 157.

WAHYOENINGRUM, S.L. (2013) ‘Seducing for Truth and Justice ’:, Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs, 32(3), pp. 115–142. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1177/186810341303200306.

WAHYUNINGROEM, S.L. (2018) ‘Working from the margins: Initiatives for truth and reconciliation for victims of the 1965 mass violence in Solo and Palu’, The Indonesian Genocide of 1965: Causes, Dynamics and Legacies, pp. 335–356.

WAHYUNINGROEM, S.L. (2019) ‘Towards post-transitional justice: the failures of transitional justice and the roles of civil society in Indonesia’, JSEAHR, 3, p. 124.

WHIGHAM, K.E. (2017) ‘Remembering to Prevent : The Preventive Capacity of Public Memory’, 11(2), pp. 53–71.

WHIGHAM, K. (2022) Resonant violence: Affect, memory, and activism in post-genocide societies. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.

WIERINGA, S.E. and Katjasungkana, N. (2019) Propaganda and the Genocide in Indonesia, Propaganda and the Genocide in Indonesia. London, New York: Routledge. Available at: https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429440243.

WIRATRAMAN, H.P. (2019) ‘Penegakan Hukum dan Penghormatan Hak Asasi Manusia’, in Imran and F.R. Hidayati (eds) Bunga Rampai Memperkuat Peradaban Hukum dan Ketatanegaraan Indonesia. Jakarta: Sekretariat Jenderal Komisi Yudisial Republik Indonesia, p. 125.

YOUNG, J.E. (2016) The stages of memory: Reflections on memorial art, loss, and the spaces between. University of Massachusetts Press.

ZURBUCHEN, M.S. (2002) ‘History, Memory, and the “1965 Incident” in Indonesia’, 2Asian Survey, 42(4), pp. 564–581.