In Search of Durable Solutions for Refugees in Indonesia: A State Security and Human Rights Protection Approach

M. Alvi Syahrin; M. Rafly  Qalandy; M. Syaran Jafizhan

doi:10.17561/tahrj.v22.8255

Authors

M. Alvi Syahrin Immigration Polytechnic
M. Rafly Qalandy Sriwijaya University
M. Syaran Jafizhan Sriwijaya University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v22.8255

Keywords:

Refugees, State Security, Human Rights, Indonesia

Abstract

The Indonesian government is experiencing difficulties in dealing with the refugee problem. This is because the number of refugees in the waiting period is increasing and the destination country limits the acceptance quota. Currently, the refugee problem in Indonesia is regulated in Presidential Regulation No. 125/2016. However, its implementation has not been optimal, as it is hampered by coordination and legal compliance factors. The implementation of the Presidential Regulation creates inconsistencies in legal norms with other regulations. Then, some local governments have begun to reject the presence of refugees. They are not willing to prepare shelters for refugees, because it burdens the budget. Currently, the government does not have a long-term solution that can be used to solve the refugee problem in Indonesia. This paper will discuss Indonesia’s role in solving the refugee problem by formulating strategic policies from a humanitarian perspective. This article uses socio-legal research with a qualitative approach. Although not a state party to the 1951 Convention, Indonesia has adopted various international laws that protect the human rights of refugees. However, its legal legitimacy is still disputed from the perspective of state security and sovereignty. Indonesia continues to be encouraged to ratify the convention to strengthen the promotion and defense of refugee rights. In fact, ratification can be a quick way to bridge the gap between international and domestic legal frameworks in addressing refugee issues in Indonesia. However, the government cannot wait to resolve this issue until the convention is ratified. There are several long-term solutions that can be practiced to address the refugee issue, including: pushing for human rights instruments to implement the basic rights of refugees; re-establishing the refugee issue as part of the National Human Rights Action Plan; revising Presidential Regulation No. 125/2016; and formulating a new policy with Indonesia, UNHCR, and giving greater authority to IOM to empower refugees while they wait to enter the destination country.

References

ADHANIAH, N., HERYADI, D. and SARI, D.S., 2021. The Cooperation of UNHCR and Indonesia on Afghan Refugee Handling in Indonesia. Andalas Journal of International Studies (AJIS), 10(1), pp. 51–65.

ALLAIN, J. 2001. The jus cogens Nature of non-refoulement. International Journal of Refugee Law 13(4), pp. 533–558.

BENHABIB, S., 2020. The end of the 1951 refugee convention? Dilemmas of sovereignty, territoriality, and human rights. Jus Cogens, 2(1), pp. 75–100.

BROWN, T.M., 2018. Building Resilience: The Emergence of Refugee-Led Education Initiatives in Indonesia to Address Service Gaps Faced in Protracted Transit. Advances in Southeast Asian Studies, 11(2), pp. 165–181.

COSTELLO, C. and MICHELLE, F., 2016. Non-refoulement as custom and jus cogens? Putting the prohibition to the test. Netherlands Yearbook of International Law 2015: Jus Cogens: Quo Vadis?, pp. 273–327.

DARMAWAN, F.D. and HERIYANTO, D.S.N., 2023. Invoking International Human Rights Law to Prevent Statelessness of International Refugee Children Born In Indonesia. Prophetic Law Review, 5(1), pp. 22–41.

DAVIES, S.E., 2008. Realistic Yet Humanitarian? The Comprehensive Plan of Action and Refugee Policy in Southeast Asia. International Relations of the Asia-Pacific, 8(2), pp. 191–217.

DEWANSYAH, B., DRAMANDA, W. and MULYANA, I., 2017. Asylum Seekers in a Non-Immigrant State and the Absence of Regional Asylum Seekers Mechanism: A Case Study of Rohingya Asylum Seekers in Aceh-Indonesia and Asean Response. Indon. L. Rev., 7, p.341.

DEWANSYAH, B. and HANDAYANI, I., 2018. Reconciling Refugee Protection and Sovereignty in ASEAN Member States: Law and Policy Related to Refugee in Indonesia, Malaysia and Thailand. the Central European Journal of International and Security Studies (CEJISS) vol, 12.

DIRECTORATE GENERAL OF IMMIGRATION. 2023. Annual Report on the Number of Refugees and Asylum Seekers in Indonesia.

FARMER, A., 2008. Non-Refoulment and jus cogens: Limiting anti-terror measures that threaten refugee protection. Geo. Immigr. LJ 23, pp. 1.

FORD, M., LYONS, L. and PALMER, W., 2010. Australia-Indonesia: Stopping the Hordes-a Critical Account of the Labor Government’s Regional Approach to the Management of Asylum Seekers. Local-Global: Identity, Security, Community, 8, pp. 28–35.

GOODWIN-GILL, G. S., 2014. The international law of refugee protection. The Oxford handbook of refugee and forced migration studies, pp. 36–47.

HUGO, G., TAN, G. and NAPITUPULU, C.J., 2017. Indonesia as a Transit Country in Irregular Migration to Australia. A long way to go: Irregular Migration Patterns, Processes, Drivers and Decision-Making, pp. 167–191.

KANG, Y.D., 2021. Refugee Crisis in Europe: Determinants of Asylum Seeking in European Countries from 2008–2014. Journal of European Integration, 43(1), pp. 33–48.

KLEIST, J. O., 2018. The refugee regime: sovereignty, belonging and the political of forced migration. Was ist ein Migrationsregime? What Is a Migration Regime?, pp. 167–185.

KNEEBONE, S., 2017. Australia as a Powerbroker on Refugee Protection in Southeast Asia: The Relationship with Indonesia. Refuge, 33, p.29.

KRANRATTANASUIT, N., 2023. Emergency, Exclusion, and Inequity in Education of Refugee and Asylum Seeker Children in Indonesia. The Social Science Journal, 60(1), pp. 75–90.

KRISTIN, D. and DEWI, C.T.I., 2021. The Rights of Children Refugee in Transit Country under the CRC, A Case of Indonesia: An Intended Negligence?. Padjadjaran Journal of International Law, 5(1), pp. 114–136.

LISTRIANI, S. and KADIR, M.Y.K.A., 2020, March. Toward a New Legal Framework for Settling Rohingya’s Refugee Crisis in Indonesia: A Lesson Learned from Aceh Province. In International Conference on Law, Governance and Islamic Society (ICOLGIS 2019) (pp. 277–285). Atlantis Press.

MISSBACH, A., 2014. Doors and Fences: Controlling Indonesia’s Porous Borders and Policing Asylum Seekers. Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography, 35(2), pp. 228–244.

MISSBACH, A. and CAMERON, T., 2022. Making do: How a Somali Refugee Woman Experiences Social Mobility Amidst Precarity in Transit in Indonesia. TRaNS: Trans-Regional and-National Studies of Southeast Asia, 10(1), pp. 85–101.

NOLA, L.F., 2021, January. Refugee Employment Prohibition in Indonesia. In ICILS 2020: Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Indonesian Legal Studies, ICILS 2020, July 1st 2020, Semarang, Indonesia (p. 294). European Alliance for Innovation.

ODUTAYO, A., 2018. Human Security and the International Refugee Crisis. In Refugee Crisis: The Borders of Human Mobility (pp. 119–133). Routledge.

PRABANDARI, A. and ADIPUTERA, Y., 2019. Alternative Paths to Refugee and Asylum Seeker Protection in Malaysia and Indonesia. Asian and Pacific Migration Journal, 28(2), pp. 132–154.

PRABANINGTYAS, R.A.R.F., 2019. Indonesia and the International Refugee Crisis: The Politics of Refugee Protection. Journal of Indonesian Social Sciences and Humanities, 9(2), pp. 131–146.

ROMAN, G. and A. TANIA., 2019. International Asylum Law: Violating Jus Cogens. Rev. Der. PR, 59, pp. 415.

SOESILOWATI, S., 2020. Cooperation between Indonesia and Australia in Managing Refugees and Asylum Seekers. International Journal of Innovation, Creativity and Change, 13(3), pp. 1–20.

SULTONI, Y., WIDAGDO, S. AND SURYOKUMORO, H., 2013. The Reason of Indonesia Not Ratified Refugee Convention 1951 and Legal Protection for Refugees in Indonesia. Jurnal Hukum, pp. 1–14.

SUMARLAN, Y, 2019. Political Economy of Pragmatic Refugee Policies in Indonesia as a Transit Country. Asian Review, 32(3), pp. 63–93.

SUYATNA, I.N., ARSIKA, I.M.B., SATYAWATI, N.G.A.D., NORDIN, R. and JONES, B., 2021. Assessment of the Responsibility of Local Governments in Indonesia for the Management of Refugee Care. Asian Journal of Law and Society, 8(3), pp. 467–489.

SYAHRIN, M.A., 2017. The Implementation of Non-Refoulement Principle to the Asylum Seekers and Refugees in Indonesia. Sriwijaya Law Review, 1(2), pp. 168–178.

SYAHRIN, M. A., 2018. The Immigration Crime and Policy: Implementation of PPNS Authorities on Investigation. JILS, 3, pp. 175.

SYAHRIN, M. A., 2021. The principle of non-refoulement as jus cogens: History, application, and Exception in international refugee law. JILS, 6, pp. 53.

SYAHRIN, M.A., WIRAPUTA, A.R. and PONCO AJI, K., 2022. Indonesian Legal Policy in Treating International Refugees Based on Human Rights Approach. Law and Humanities Quarterly Reviews, 1(4).

TAN, D., 2021. Metode Penelitian Hukum: Mengupas Dan Mengulas Metodologi Dalam Menyelenggarakan Penelitian Hukum. Nusantara: Jurnal Ilmu Pengetahuan Sosial, 8(8), pp. 2463–2478.

TAZREITER, C., 2006. Between state sovereignty and invisibility: monitoring the human rights of returned asylum seekers. Australian Journal of Human Rights, 12(1), pp. 7–25.

TAYLOR, S. and RAFFERTY-BROWN, B., 2010. Difficult Journeys: Accessing Refugee Protection in Indonesia. Monash UL Rev., 36, p.138.

TOBING, D.H., 2021. Connecting the Obligation Gap: Indonesia’s Non-Refoulement Responsibility Beyond the 1951 Refugee Convention. Asian Journal of Law and Society, 8(3), pp. 521–535.