Human Right to Health, Social Rights and Human Dignity versus Relativist Challenge of Neoliberal Capitalism
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v25.9272Keywords:
Dignity , Care , human right to health,, health care in emergencies, economic and social rights, Neoliberal capitalism, Sustainable development, human rightsAbstract
Human rights to health and health care have developed considerably since they were first codified after World War Two and now, they are regulated in many international and national legal documents. Nevertheless, health rights still face many challenges. They are among the most contested, incompletely conceptualized human rights and the least enforceable rights. This paper argues that the greatest challenges and difficulties in health rights stem from the global expansion of neoliberal capitalism to which positivist epistemology is complacent. These problems entail the relativist challenge to the universality of human dignity and the neglect of fundamental values such as caring, empathy and respect for human dignity. The neoliberal capitalist mindset leads to an erosion of empathy, which translates into hostility towards, or at least neglect of, social human rights. All this contributes to the normalization of narrow understandings of health and the human right to health and to the problematic development of health rights. The commodification of health care led to a paradigm shift in the health sector creating an impersonal, profit-centric relationship. The insufficient role of the World Health Organization is one of the main reasons for the underdevelopment of health rights. Nor can the concept of sustainable development be seen as truly inclusive and conducive to the development of viable health rights, as the problems in the development of universal health coverage show. This paper suggests that the creation of fully-fledged health rights is not a problem of resource scarcity or lack of legal norms — but primarily a problem of scarcity of care and empathy, and a lack of understanding of the universality of human dignity. To make health and health care full-fledged human rights requires, first and foremost, a cultural transformation and mental revival, which would revive care, empathy, and dignity; the development of social rights that are indispensable for the protection of human dignity; and the implementation of a solidaristic perspective with full decommodification of health care.
Downloads
References
ALDERSON, P. (2016). ‘The philosophy of critical realism and childhood studies’, Global Studies of Childhood, 6(2), pp.199-210.
ALVAREZ J. E. (2022). ‘The Missing Global Right to Health’, Proceedings of the ASIL Annual Meeting, 116, pp. 3-6. Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/amp.2023.3
AMADAE, S. (2016). Prisoners of reason: Game theory and neoliberal political economy. NY: Cambridge University.
BARRETO, J. (2006). ‘Ethics of Emotions as Ethics of Human Rights: A Jurisprudence of Sympathy in Adorno, Horkheimer and Rorty’, Law Critique, 17. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10978-006-0003-y
BENACH, J. (2021). ‘We Must Take Advantage of This Pandemic to Make a Radical Social Change: The Coronavirus as a Global Health, Inequality, and Eco-Social Problem’, International Journal of Health Services, 51(1). https://doi.org/10.1177/0020731420946594
BHASKAR, R., DANERMARK, B. and PRICE, L. (2017). Interdisciplinarity and Wellbeing: A Critical Realist General Theory of Interdisciplinarity. London: Routledge
BHASKAR, R. and HARTWIG, M. (2016). Enlightened Common Sense: The Philosophy of Critical Realism. London: Routledge.
BREILH, J. (2021). Critical Epidemiology and the People’s Health. Oxford University Press.
BUZELLI, M. and BOYCE, T. (2021). ‘The Privatization of the Italian National Health System and its Impact on Health Emergency Preparedness and Response: The COVID-19 Case’, International Journal of Health Services, 51(4), pp. 501-508.
CALLISON, W. (2019). Political Deficits: The Dawn of Neoliberal Rationality and the Eclipse of Critical Theory. Ph.D Dissertation, University of California, Berkeley. https://escholarship.org/uc/item/9p0574bc
CATALÁN, E. A. (2022). ‘The right of access to healthcare: tracing solidarity in the United Nations, Inter-American and European human Rights systems, European Society of International Law Paper- AEL 2022/01, Academy of European Law.
Constitution of the World Health Organization. Global Health and Human Rights. Retrieved from: https://www.globalhealthrights.org/instrument/constitution-of-the-world-health-organization-who/
CORSO L. (2014). ‘Should empathy Play any Role in the Interpretation of Constitutional Rights?’ Ratio Juris, 27(1). https://doi.org/10.1111/RAJU.12037
CRUFT, R., LIAO, M. and RENZO, M, (2015). ‘The Philosophical Foundations of Human Rights: An Overview’, in R. Cruft, S. Liao and M. Renzo (eds.). Philosophical Foundations of Human Rights. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
DALLI, M. (2018). ‘The human right to health: a retrospective analysis after 70 years of international recognition’, The Age of Human Rights Journal, (11), pp. 24-42.
Declaration of Alma-Ata, WHO Europe. Retrieved from: https://iris.who.int/bitstream/handle/10665/347879/WHO-EURO-1978-3938-43697-61471-eng.pdf?sequence=1
Declaration of Astana, WHO’s Global Conference on Primary Health Care in Astana, 2018.
DORFMAN, A. and HAREL, A. (2016). ‘Against privatisation as such’, Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, 36(2), pp. 400-427.
ECtHR, Mehmet Şentürk and Bekir Şentürk v Turkey, 9 April 2013. Retrieved from: https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng#{%22itemid%22:[%22001-118722%22]}
E/C.12/2000/4: CESCR General Comment No. 14: The Right to the Highest Attainable Standard. Retrieved from: www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/Documents/Issues/Women/WRGS/Health/GC14.pdf
EMERSON, B. (2021). ‘Public Care in Public Law: Structure, Procedure, and Purpose’, Harv. L. & Pol’y Rev., 16(35).
EMMEL, N. (1998). ‘Health-for-All for 21st Century: Demise of Primary Health Care’, Economic and Political Weekly, 33(11). Retrieved from: http://www.jstor.org/stable/4406519
ENGEL, G. L. (1977). ‘The need for a new medical model: a challenge for biomedicine’, Science, 196 (4286), pp. 129–136.
ERK, Ch. (2011). Health, Rights and Dignity: Philosophical Reflections on an Alleged Human Right. Ontos Verlag.
FLETCHER, E. (2023). ‘UN Political Declaration on Universal Health Coverage: Ambitious Aspirations Against Litany of Failures’, Health Policy Watch. September 15. Retrieved from: https://healthpolicy-watch.news/un-political-declaration-on-universal-health-coverage-ambitious-reach-against-autopsy-of-failures-to-date/
FLOOD, C. M. and GROSS, A. (2014). ‘Litigating the right to health: What can we learn from a comparative law and health care systems approach’, Health and Human Rights, 16, 62.
FREEMAN, M. (2015). ‘Neoliberal Policies and Human Rights’, Dokuz Eylül Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi, 17(2). https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/753653.
FREUDENBERG, N. (2021). At What Cost: Modern Capitalism and the Future of Health. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
FRIEDMAN, E. et al. (2020). ‘Global Health in the age of COVID-19: responsive health systems through a right to health fund’, Health and human rights, 22 (1), 199.
GAFFNEY, A. (2017). To Heal Humankind: The Right to Health in History. NY: Routledge.
GAFFNEY, A. and MUNTANER, C. (2018). ‘Austerity and health care’, in H. Waitzkin and Working Group for Health Beyond Capitalism (eds.) Health Care under the Knife: Moving beyond Capitalism for Our Health (pp.119-135). NY: Monthly Review Press.
GOODMAN, T. (2005). ‘Is there a right to health?’ The Journal of medicine and philosophy, 30(6), pp. 643-662.
GOSTIN, L. O., MEIER, B. M., THOMAS, R., MAGAR, V. and GHEBREYESUS, T. A. (2018). ’70 years of human rights in global health: drawing on a contentious past to secure a hopeful future’, The Lancet, 392(10165), pp. 2731-2735.
GUPTA, J., BAVINCK, M., ROS-TONEN, M., ASUBONTENG, K. et al. (2021). ‘COVID-19, poverty and inclusive development’, World Development, 145, 105527.
GUPTA, J., POUW, N. and ROS-TONEN, A. (2015). ‘Towards an Elaborated Theory of Inclusive Development’, European Journal of Development Research, 27(4).
GUPTA, J. and VEGELIN, C. (2016). ‘Sustainable development goals and inclusive development’, International environmental agreements, 16, pp. 433-448.
HABERMAS, J. (2010). ‘The concept of human dignity and the realistic utopia of human rights’, Metaphilosophy, 41(4), pp. 464–80.
HALL, J. and TAYLOR, R. (2003). ‘Health for all beyond 2000: the demise of the Alma-Ata Declaration and primary health care in developing countries’, The Medical Journal of Australia, 178(1), pp. 17-20.
HARRINGTON, J. and STUTTAFORD, M. (2010). ‘Introduction’, in J. Harrington and M. Stuttaford (eds.) Global health and human rights: legal and philosophical perspectives (pp. 1-12). NY: Routledge.
HESSELMAN, M. and TOEBES, B. (2015). ‘The human right to health and climate change: a legal perspective. Input to the study of the OHCHR pursuant to HRC Resolution 29/15 31’, Global Health Law Groningen Working Paper. Groningen University.
HIMMELSTEIN, D. and WOOLHANDLER, S. (2018). ‘The political economy of health reform’, in H. Waitzkin and Working Group for Health Beyond Capitalism (eds.), Health Care under the Knife: Moving beyond Capitalism for Our Health (pp. 57-68). NY: Monthly Review Press.
HUNT, L. (2007). Inventing Human Rights. History. NY: W. Norton.
HUNT, P. (2016). ‘Interpreting the international right to health in a human rights-based approach to health’, Health and Human Rights, 18(2), pp. 109-130.
International Covenant on Economic, Soial and Cultural Rights, 1966. UN Human Rights, Office of The High Commissioner. Retrieved from: www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/international-covenant-economic-social-and-cultural-rights
ISSEL, L. (2014). ‘It’s health care, not healthcare’, Health Care Manage Rev., 39(4), https://doi.org/10.1097/HMR.0000000000000040
JUNG, C., HIRSCHL, R. and ROSEVEAR, E. (2014). ‘Economic and social rights in national constitutions’, The American Journal of Comparative Law, 62(4), pp. 1043-1094.
KALDOR, J. C., GOSTIN, L. O., MONAHAN, J. T. and GOTTSCHALK, K. (2020). ‘The Lancet–O’Neill Institute/Georgetown University Commission on global health and law: The power of law to advance the right to health’, Public Health Ethics, 13(1), pp. 9-15
KANNAN, S., BRUCH, J. and SONG, Z. (2023). ‘Changes in Hospital Adverse Events and Patient Outcomes Associated With Private Equity Acquisition’, JAMA. 330(24), pp. 2365–2375. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2023.23147
KENNETT, J. (2017). ‘Examining Neoliberalism and Mental Health Strategy — A Discursive Analysis of a UK Department of Health Document’. MMU Psychology Journal (Dissertations). Manchester Metropolitan University. https://e-space.mmu.ac.uk/619203/
KHOO, E. J. and LANTOS, J. D. (2020). ‘Lessons learned from the COVID-19 pandemic’, Acta Paediatrica, 109(7), pp. 1323-1325. https://doi.org/10.1111/apa.15307
KHOO, S.-M. (2015). ‘Solidarity, equity and rights-based to health provision’, Commonwealth Health Partnerships -2015. Commonwealth Secretariat. http://hdl.handle.net/10379/6790
KITTAY, E. (2005). ‘Equality, Dignity and Disability’, in M. Waldron and F. Lyons (eds.). Perspectives on Equality: The Second Seamus Heaney Lectures. Dublin: Liffey.
KITTAY, E. (2011). ‘The Ethics of Care, Dependence, and Disability’. Ratio Juris, 24(1).
KITTAY, E. (2019). Learning from my daughter: The value and care of disabled minds. Oxford University Press.
LI, A. M. (2017). ‘Ecological determinants of health: food and environment on human health’, Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 24(10), pp. 9002-9015.
LUONGO, B. (2021). ‘Critical Realism, Human Rights, and Emotion: How an Emotive Ontology Can Resolve the Tensions Between Universalism and Relativism’, Human Rights Review, 22(2), pp. 217-238.
MANFREDI, Z. (2018). ‘An unlikely resonance? Subjects of human rights and subjects of human capital reconsidered’, in B. Golder, D. McLoughlin (eds.). The Politics of Legality in a Neoliberal Age. NY: Routledge.
MARKS, S. (2013). ‘The emergence and scope of the human right to health’, in S. Marks, J. Zuniga and L. Gostin (eds.). Advancing the human right to health (pp. 3-24). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
MAROCHINI, M. (2013). ‘Council of Europe and the right to healthcare-is the European Convention on Human Rights appropriate instrument for protecting the right to healthcare?’ Zbornik Pravnog fakulteta Sveučilišta u Rijeci, 34(2), 729-760.
MASSA, A. A., VILLOUTA, M. B. and FERRADA, C. R. (2021). ‘Sanctioning Chile’s public health care system for not providing basic services to the elderly: The Inter-American Court’s Poblete Vilches Ruling’. Health and Human Rights, 23(1), 251.
MCCLEAR, S. (2025). ‘The Perilous Spread of the Wellness Craze’, The Atlantic, May 29. Retrieved from: https://www.theatlantic.com/books/archive/2025/05/how-health-became-luxury-commodity/682957/
MCGREGOR, S. (2001). ‘Neoliberalism and health care’, Int J Consum Stud, 25(2), pp. 82-89.
MEGUID, T. (2016). ‘(Re)Humanising Health Care – Placing Dignity and Agency of the Patient at the Centre’, Nordic Journal of Human Rights, 34(1), pp. 60-64. https://doi.org/10.1080/18918131.2016.1153189
MEIER, B. et al. (2023). ‘A critical juncture for human rights in global health: Strengthening human rights through global health law reforms’, PLOS Glob Public Health, 3(12). https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgph.0002663
MEIER, B. (2010a). ‘Global health governance and the contentious politics of human rights: Mainstreaming the right to health for public health advancement’, Stanford Journal of International Law, 46(1), pp. 1-50. https://bmeier.web.unc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/700/2011/08/Meier-2010-2.pdf
MEIER, B. (2010b). ‘The World Health Organisation, the Evolution of Human Rights and the Failure to Achieve Health’, in J. Harrington and M. Stuttaford (eds.). Global health and human rights: legal and philosophical perspectives. NY: Routledge.
MEIER, B. M. and FOX, A. M. (2013). International obligations through collective rights: Moving from foreign health assistance to global health governance. Health & Hum. Rts., 12, 61.
METCALF, S. (2017). ‘Neoliberalism: the idea that swallowed the world’. Guardian, August 18. https://www.theguardian.com/news/2017/aug/18/neoliberalism-the-idea-that-changed-the-world
MISZTAL, B. (2013). ‘The idea of dignity: Its modern significance’, European Journal of Social Theory, 16(1), pp. 101-121.
MOREFIELD, J. (2020). ‘When Neoliberalism Hijacked Human Rights’, Jacobin, May 1. https://www.jacobinmag.com/2020/01/morals-markets-human-rights-rise-neoliberalism-jessica-whyte
MURPHY, T. (2013). Health and human rights. Oxford: Hart publishing.
MUYSKENS, K. (2022). ‘A Human Right to What Kind of Health?’, Ethics and Social Welfare, 16(4), pp. 364-379.
NÉILL, CÓ. (2021). ‘A global right to health amid global health emergencies’, in CÓ. Néill, et al. (eds.) Routledge Handbook of Global Health Rights. (pp. 47-61). NY: Routledge.
OBANI, P. and J. GUPTA. (2017). ‘Inclusive development as an imperative to realizing the human right to water and sanitation’, Journal of Sustainable Development Law and Policy, 8(2), pp. 67-86.
O’CONNELL, P. (2007). ‘On reconciling irreconcilables: Neo-liberal globalisation and human rights’, Human Rights Law Review, 7(3), pp. 483-509.
O’CONNELL, P. (2010). ‘The human right to health in an age of market hegemony’, in J. Harrington and M. Stuttaford (eds.) Global health and human rights: legal and philosophical perspectives (pp.190-210). NY: Routledge.
ONGE, J. (2017). ‘Neoliberalism as Common Sense in Barack Obama’s Health Care Rhetoric’, Rhetoric Society Quarterly, 47(4).
Poblete Vilches and others v Chile (Merits, Reparations and Costs) Inter-American Court of Human Rights, 2018. March 8. https://www.escr-net.org/caselaw/2019/poblete-vilches-and-others-v-chile/
Political Declaration of the High-level Meeting on Universal Health Coverage, 2019. Retrieved from: https://www.un.org/pga/73/wp-content/uploads/sites/53/2019/07/FINAL-draft-UHC-Political-Declaration.pdf.
PORTER, C. (2007). ‘Ottawa to Bangkok: changing health promotion discourse’, Health Promot Int.; 22(1), pp. 72-79. https://doi.org/10.1093/HEAPRO/DAL037
PORTO, M., FERREIRA, D. and FINAMORE, R. (2017). ‘Health as dignity: political ecology, epistemology and challenges to environmental justice movements’, Journal of Political Ecology, 24(1), pp. 110-124.
PRATA, J., RIBEIRO, A. and ROCHA-SANTOS, T. (2022). ‘An introduction to the concept of One Health’, in Joana C. Prata, Ana Isabel Ribeiro, Teresa Rocha-Santos (eds). One Health (pp. 1-31). Academic Press.
RAINE, S., LIU, A., MINTZ, J., WAHOOD, W., HUNTLEY, K. and HAFFIZULLA, F. (2020). ‘Racial and Ethnic Disparities in COVID-19 Outcomes: Social Determination of Health’, International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(21).
RAMMELT, C. and GUPTA J. (2021). ‘Inclusive is not an adjective, it transforms development: A post-growth interpretation of Inclusive Development’, Environmental Science & Policy, 124, pp. 144-155. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1462901121001726
RUGER, J. (2008). ‘Normative foundations of global health law’, Georgetown Law Journal, 96(2).
Rural Hospital Closures: Number and Characteristics of Affected Hospitals and Contributing Factors (2018). GAO-18-634, August 29. Retrieved from: https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-18-634
SANGHERA, B. and SATYBALDIEVA E. (2021). Rentier Capitalism and Its Discontents. Cham: Springer International Publishing.
SAVAGE, C. (2025). ‘With Supreme Court Ruling, Another Check on Trump’s Power Fades’, New York Times, June 28. https://www.nytimes.com/2025/06/28/us/supreme-court-trump-executive-branch-power.html
SAYER, A. (2011). Why things matter to people: social science, values and ethical life. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
SAYER, A. (2017a). ‘Values within reason’, Canadian Review of Sociology, 54(4), pp. 468-475.
SAYER, A. (2017b). ‘Critique and naturalism’. In U. Lindner and D. Mader (Eds.), Critical Realism Meets Kritische-Theorie (pp. 315-337). Bielefeld: Transcript Verlag.
SAYER, A. (2018). ‘Welfare and moral economy’, Ethics and Social Welfare, 12(1), pp. 20-33, https://doi.org/10.1080/17496535.2017.1377273
SCHULTZ, N. (2013). Empathy as the key to equality and human rights: an investigation of empathy’s role in inter-group relations and discrimination. Doctoral Dissertation. Poznan: Adam Mickiewicz University. https://repository.gchumanrights.org/han-dle/20.500.11825/643
SCOTT-SAMUEL, A., BAMBRA, C., et al. (2014). ‘The impact of Thatcherism on health and well-being in Britain’, International Journal of Health Services, 44(1), pp. 53-71.
STEIGLEDER, K. (2014). ‘Human Dignity and Social Welfare’. In M. Düwell, et al. (Eds.), The Cambridge Handbook of Human Dignity: Interdisciplinary Perspectives (pp. 471–76). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Super rich hold $32 trillion in offshore havens (2022). Reuters. July 22. Retrieved from: https://www.reuters.com/article/business/super-rich-hold-32-trillion-in-offshore-havens-idUSBRE86L03V/
TASIOULAS, J. (2017). ‘Minimum core obligations: Human rights in the here and now’. World Bank. Retrieved from: http://hdl.handle.net/10986/29144 License
The Bangkok Charter for Health Promotion in a Globalized World (2005). World Health Organization. Retrieved from: https://www.who.int/teams/health-promotion/enhanced-wellbeing/sixth-global-conference/the-bangkok-charter
TOBIN, J. (2012). The Right to Health in International Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
TURK, V. (2024). ‘Revitalising the right to health is essential to securing better health for all’, The Lancet, 403(10434), pp. 1315-1318.
TURNER, B. S. (1993). ‘Outline of a theory of human rights’, Sociology, 27(3), pp. 489-512.
Universal Health Coverage (2025). World Health Organization, 26 March. Retrieved from: https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/universal-health-coverage-(uhc).
VANG, J. and S. HAJIOFF. (2002). ‘Rationalizing hospital services’, in M. McKee, J. Healy and J. Falkingham (eds.). Health care in Central Asia. Buckingham: Open University Press.
View the ratification status by country or by treaty, United Nations Human Rights Treaty Bodies. Retrieved from: https://tbinternet.ohchr.org/_layouts/15/TreatyBodyExternal/Treaty.aspx?Treaty=CCPR&Lang=en
WAITZKIN, H. (2018). ‘Introduction: What We’re Trying to Do Here and Why?’, in: H. Waitzkin and Working Group for Health Beyond Capitalism (eds), Health Care under the Knife: Moving beyond Capitalism for Our Health. NY: Monthly Review Press.
WAITZKIN, H. (2020). ‘Moving beyond capitalism for our health’, International Journal of Health Services, 50(4), pp. 458-462.
WAITZKIN, H. (2021). ‘COVID-19 as Cause versus Trigger for the Collapse of Capitalism’, International Journal of Health Services, 51(2). https://doi.org/10.1177/0020731420977711
Why more Americans are putting off going to the doctor (2023). PBS Weekend, March 25. Retrieved from: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/why-more-americans-are-putting-off-going-to-the-doctor
WHYTE, J. (2019). The Morals of the Market: Human Rights and the Rise of Neoliberalism. London: Verso Books.
WILSON, R. (2020). Learning from Daughter. Ethics of Care. https://ethicsofcare.org/learning-from-my-daughter/
WOLFF, J. (2012, June). ‘I—The Demands of the Human Right to Health’, Aristotelian Society Supplementary Volume, Blackwell Publishing, 86(1), pp. 217-237.
WOODRUFF, J. (2025). Robert Putnam reflects on how America became so polarized and what can unify the nation. PBS News, February 19. Retrieved from: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/robert-putnam-reflects-on-how-america-became-so-polarized-and-what-can-unify-the-nation
YAMIN, A. (2008). Will We Take Suffering Seriously? Reflections on What Applying a Human Rights Framework to Heath Means and Why We Should Care’, Health & Human Rights, 10(1), pp. 45-63.
YAMIN, A. (2015). Power, suffering, and the struggle for dignity: Human rights frameworks for health and why they matter. University of Pennsylvania Press.
YAROSHENKO, O., STESHENKO, V., TARASOV, O., NURULLAIEV, I. and SHVARTSEVA, M. (2022). Right to health care: the practice of the ECTHR and the case of Ukraine. The Age of Human Rights Journal, (18), pp. 239-256.
ZHAJETOVA, Z. (2022). ‘Za chto my platim i pochemu OSMS ne garantiruyet kazakhstantsam kachestvennoy meditsinskoy pomoshchi’. Informburo, July 26. Retrieved from: https://informburo.kz/interview/za-cto-my-platim-i-pocemu-osms-ne-garantiruet-kazaxstancam-kacestvennoi-medicinskoi-pomoshhi-mnenie-eksperta
ZHUSSIPBEK, G. (2025). If human rights are ignored, democracy becomes a plaything for populists, TEDxAstana Salon. www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Ib7poU4CT4&t=1s
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Galym Zhussipbek
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
